Bike Forums

Bike Forums (https://www.bikeforums.net/forum.php)
-   Commuting (https://www.bikeforums.net/commuting/)
-   -   fender that attaches underneath rear rack? on road bike with minimal brake clearance (https://www.bikeforums.net/commuting/526036-fender-attaches-underneath-rear-rack-road-bike-minimal-brake-clearance.html)

TallRider 03-31-09 09:50 AM

fender that attaches underneath rear rack? on road bike with minimal brake clearance
 
2 Attachment(s)
I'm building my old Raleigh back up with parts I have sitting around, and want to make it somewhat weatherproof. Rear fender is most important to me. Now, it has very little clearance underneath the brakes and against the seat tube, even with 700x23c tires, so I can't use a normal fender. However, I have a rear rack on the bike, which I intend to use with a rack-top trunk.

And I'm wondering if there are fender designs that I can attach to the underside of the rack, with zip-ties or something. Here are a couple of photos. This wouldn't protect the brakes or seat-tube/drivetrain area, but would keep spray from going up on my back.
Thanks for any thoughts or feedback here.

CliftonGK1 03-31-09 10:18 AM

Why not use a clip-on fender like a Speed-EZ?

TallRider 03-31-09 11:58 AM

that's my other option, and may be the better option. since I hope to use the bike for some light (unloaded) touring, it may be better to just buy those.

Something like the speed-EZ fenders but with a more durable mounting system would be nice - when I read reviews there are some of complaints about the mounting system crapping out. SKS Raceblades are a similar option that gets better reviews. Topeak also makes the R1/R2 which is a similar model.
And fenders like this would protect my rear brake as well as my back and rack-top pack, although not the drivetrain.

wristwister 03-31-09 12:06 PM

I just picked up a Specialized with the same problem, zero clearance for a rear fender. I wanted better coverage than those clip-ons. Bike shop fixed me right up. I bought standard full venders, they sliced the rear one in two and mounted the halves to either side of the frame/caliper with a slick little bracket that held it all together. I assumed this bracket was an off-the-shelf solution and not something custom. Works and looks real slick! If you're interested, I can take a pic sometime in the next day or 2 and post it.

TallRider 03-31-09 12:24 PM

wristwister, I'd be interested to see a picture of your mounting setup.
however, it may not help with my Raleigh. That bike has very short chainstays, and you can see in the above picture that the tire is very close to the seat tube as-is... and that's with 23mm tires.

It's not a huge deal because I'm planning to keep the bike in California and only ride it when I'm out there to visit; the main reason I want some kind of fender is for a 2-week ride I'm planning to do from Seattle to San Francisco. In July, so rain won't be much of an issue, but still gives me pause.

mechanicalron 03-31-09 01:52 PM

I use my old tires for fenders.
http://i183.photobucket.com/albums/x...ce/sick002.jpg
http://i183.photobucket.com/albums/x...ce/sick005.jpg

noglider 03-31-09 02:47 PM

You don't need a special fender. I recommend getting a rack that sits higher.

TallRider 03-31-09 04:11 PM

desire for special fender is because of minimal clearance around the rear wheel, as specified in my initial post. The rack is not a problem with clearance, only the brakes and seat tube.
I mentioned the rack only because I thought it might be useful to rig up some sort of fender that attaches to the underside of the rack.

JanMM 03-31-09 04:54 PM

The rack looks plenty high for fenders. Doesn't look like an issue at all.
The brake looks pretty close to the tire, though.

TallRider 03-31-09 05:57 PM


Originally Posted by JanMM (Post 8638229)
The rack looks plenty high for fenders. Doesn't look like an issue at all.
The brake looks pretty close to the tire, though.

That's exactly what I said in my original post:


Originally Posted by timcupery (Post 8635054)
...Now, it has very little clearance underneath the brakes and against the seat tube, even with 700x23c tires, so I can't use a normal fender. However, I have a rear rack on the bike, which I intend to use with a rack-top trunk...
And I'm wondering if there are fender designs that I can attach to the underside of the rack, with zip-ties or something.

It's like a lot of road bikes. I think I'll end up getting clip-on fenders (SKS Raceblade, Planet Bike Speed-EZ).


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 04:27 PM.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.