I am trying to decide whether to get pedal straps or go for cleats and pedals with clips. I primarily use my ride for commuting in downtown Seattle, so it is usually wet. Also to consider is that I have size 13 shoes, so the toe cage type pedals that I currently have don't fit and are currently a problem, my foot won't go far enough in so I'm pedaling with my toes.
I'm thinking of going with either a strap like this one:
The problem with cleats, is I have no idea what buy. I already made enough mistakes with my bike, I don't want to waste another $200 on shoes and clips that aren't right for my application.