Bike computer w/ GPS tracking
#1
Senior Member
Thread Starter
Bike computer w/ GPS tracking
What bike computer w/ GPS, has true tracking capability?
The Best Bike GPS of 2016 | Top Ten Reviews
The reason I am asking. Is because, the Android phone I have, is a pain in the (you know). Because, It is not good for someone with eye-hand coordination, and fine-motor skill, problems. So, I am going back to using a flip phone. While that will take care of my disgust about the Android phone. That doesn't solve the tracking problem.
Any feedback as a bike computer that would make it possible for Police/EMS to track and find a cyclist.
I have both, the Garmin Edge 200, and the Garmin Edge 500. The 500 tells me where I have been. But it can't be tracked. At the included website, it doesn't say if any of the bike computers have GPS tracking.
The Best Bike GPS of 2016 | Top Ten Reviews
The reason I am asking. Is because, the Android phone I have, is a pain in the (you know). Because, It is not good for someone with eye-hand coordination, and fine-motor skill, problems. So, I am going back to using a flip phone. While that will take care of my disgust about the Android phone. That doesn't solve the tracking problem.
Any feedback as a bike computer that would make it possible for Police/EMS to track and find a cyclist.
I have both, the Garmin Edge 200, and the Garmin Edge 500. The 500 tells me where I have been. But it can't be tracked. At the included website, it doesn't say if any of the bike computers have GPS tracking.
#2
Senior Member
Join Date: Sep 2007
Location: Far beyond the pale horizon.
Posts: 14,228
Mentioned: 31 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 4217 Post(s)
Liked 1,313 Times
in
910 Posts
All the cycling computers that provide remote tracking use a smartphone.
The Garmin Edge Explore 1000 has "incident reporting" (probably, the only device that does that).
Garmin releases new Edge Explore 1000 Edition: Tells your friends when you crash into a ditch | DC Rainmaker
These devices provide tracking without needing a cell phone but they are not cycle computers.
FindMeSPOT.com
You have to press a "rescue me" button or fail to "report in" to get help.
The Garmin Edge Explore 1000 has "incident reporting" (probably, the only device that does that).
Garmin releases new Edge Explore 1000 Edition: Tells your friends when you crash into a ditch | DC Rainmaker
These devices provide tracking without needing a cell phone but they are not cycle computers.
FindMeSPOT.com
You have to press a "rescue me" button or fail to "report in" to get help.
Last edited by njkayaker; 12-11-15 at 09:01 AM.
#3
Senior Member
Join Date: Mar 2010
Location: Seattle, WA
Posts: 23,208
Mentioned: 89 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 18883 Post(s)
Liked 10,644 Times
in
6,053 Posts
Some of the Garmin devices have a LiveTracking feature, but it requires a smart phone (like the Android you gave up). In an accident it's really only of use if somebody at home is watching your progress when you get hit. That wasn't the case in my accident. The Edge 1000 has a "crash detection" feature but it also requires a smart phone.
An InReach or SPOT device can leave a bread crumb trail and it goes through a system that's used for search and rescue. These devices are fairly expensive and carry a monthly fee because they go through a for-profit satellite network. These have an SOS button, so if nobody is watching the trail at home, you can call for help as long as your hands aren't broken and you can reach the device.
#4
Senior Member
Thread Starter
All the cycling computers that provide remote tracking use a smartphone.
The Garmin Edge Explore 1000 has "incident reporting" (probably, the only device that does that).
Garmin releases new Edge Explore 1000 Edition: Tells your friends when you crash into a ditch | DC Rainmaker
These devices provide tracking without needing a cell phone but they are not cycle computers.
FindMeSPOT.com
You have to press a "rescue me" button or fail to "report in" to get help.
The Garmin Edge Explore 1000 has "incident reporting" (probably, the only device that does that).
Garmin releases new Edge Explore 1000 Edition: Tells your friends when you crash into a ditch | DC Rainmaker
These devices provide tracking without needing a cell phone but they are not cycle computers.
FindMeSPOT.com
You have to press a "rescue me" button or fail to "report in" to get help.
Think about how that would likely come into play.
Some of the Garmin devices have a LiveTracking feature, but it requires a smart phone (like the Android you gave up). In an accident it's really only of use if somebody at home is watching your progress when you get hit. That wasn't the case in my accident. The Edge 1000 has a "crash detection" feature but it also requires a smart phone.
An InReach or SPOT device can leave a bread crumb trail and it goes through a system that's used for search and rescue. These devices are fairly expensive and carry a monthly fee because they go through a for-profit satellite network. These have an SOS button, so if nobody is watching the trail at home, you can call for help as long as your hands aren't broken and you can reach the device.
Some of the Garmin devices have a LiveTracking feature, but it requires a smart phone (like the Android you gave up). In an accident it's really only of use if somebody at home is watching your progress when you get hit. That wasn't the case in my accident. The Edge 1000 has a "crash detection" feature but it also requires a smart phone.
An InReach or SPOT device can leave a bread crumb trail and it goes through a system that's used for search and rescue. These devices are fairly expensive and carry a monthly fee because they go through a for-profit satellite network. These have an SOS button, so if nobody is watching the trail at home, you can call for help as long as your hands aren't broken and you can reach the device.
#5
Senior Member
Join Date: Sep 2015
Location: Twin Cities, MN
Posts: 120
Bikes: Surly CC
Mentioned: 0 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 1 Post(s)
Likes: 0
Liked 0 Times
in
0 Posts
What bike computer w/ GPS, has true tracking capability?
The Best Bike GPS of 2016 | Top Ten Reviews
The reason I am asking. Is because, the Android phone I have, is a pain in the (you know). Because, It is not good for someone with eye-hand coordination, and fine-motor skill, problems. So, I am going back to using a flip phone. While that will take care of my disgust about the Android phone. That doesn't solve the tracking problem.
Any feedback as a bike computer that would make it possible for Police/EMS to track and find a cyclist.
I have both, the Garmin Edge 200, and the Garmin Edge 500. The 500 tells me where I have been. But it can't be tracked. At the included website, it doesn't say if any of the bike computers have GPS tracking.
The Best Bike GPS of 2016 | Top Ten Reviews
The reason I am asking. Is because, the Android phone I have, is a pain in the (you know). Because, It is not good for someone with eye-hand coordination, and fine-motor skill, problems. So, I am going back to using a flip phone. While that will take care of my disgust about the Android phone. That doesn't solve the tracking problem.
Any feedback as a bike computer that would make it possible for Police/EMS to track and find a cyclist.
I have both, the Garmin Edge 200, and the Garmin Edge 500. The 500 tells me where I have been. But it can't be tracked. At the included website, it doesn't say if any of the bike computers have GPS tracking.
I had a Spot 2 for backpacking at one point but returned it. The cost of the device + the annual subscription + what it really provided did not equate to what I really needed.
#6
Senior Member
Thread Starter
What is your real worry/desire? Are you worried that you'll go down (crash) someplace without help, are you just looking to track your routes or if you're missing for too long do you want a service/person to be able to ping where you are?
I had a Spot 2 for backpacking at one point but returned it. The cost of the device + the annual subscription + what it really provided did not equate to what I really needed.
I had a Spot 2 for backpacking at one point but returned it. The cost of the device + the annual subscription + what it really provided did not equate to what I really needed.
I have three lifelong physical neurological health conditions. That aren't exactly 'chicken feed', when it comes to severity.
I want someone to be able to find me if something happens, and I can't contact anyone on the emerg. contact list.
#7
Senior Member
Thread Starter
#8
Senior Member
Join Date: Mar 2010
Location: Seattle, WA
Posts: 23,208
Mentioned: 89 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 18883 Post(s)
Liked 10,644 Times
in
6,053 Posts
GPS is just a listener, it's like a radio that plays music and the news, the station doesn't know you're listening. For someone to track you via GPS, you also need a transmitter. Like a phone.
#9
Senior Member
Join Date: Sep 2007
Location: Far beyond the pale horizon.
Posts: 14,228
Mentioned: 31 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 4217 Post(s)
Liked 1,313 Times
in
910 Posts
I'd call what you are looking for "remote tracking". "Tracking" could refer to "recording a track" or "transmitting/sending position/track data to a remote party".
The Edge 1000 Explore solves 1 "reasonably well". One might be able to use a smartphone with an accelerometer.
https://itunes.apple.com/us/app/kael...847680838?mt=8
Things like the Spot allow you to "check in" periodically. I don't see how automatically "checking in" can be done reliably at this point (one could use HR but that would only determine that you were dead). I suppose to missing the ETA to waypoints could be used but I don't know any device that does that. Having the "check in" at any regularity sounds like a nuisance.
For 2 (sending the information to your emergeny contact), there appear to be two available options: 1- using a smartphone to call somebody, and 2- using a satellite network like the Spot devices do (keep in mind that these are communication statellites not GPS statellites).
(Note that you probably aren't going to have whatever you use contact EMS directly.)
===============
As far as I can tell, the only option that could work for you is the Edge 1000 Explore linked to a smartphone OR just a smartphone with an "incident detection" app.
The Spot won't work because it can't determine "something happened" by itself (you are stuck with using a "send help" button or manually "checking in" periodically). You could do the same thing with a cellphone (though the Spot isn't limited to places with cell-phone reception).
Last edited by njkayaker; 12-14-15 at 12:00 PM.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
meanwhile
Electronics, Lighting, & Gadgets
12
04-06-11 10:51 AM