Bike Forums

Bike Forums (http://www.bikeforums.net/forum.php)
-   Electronics, Lighting, & Gadgets (http://www.bikeforums.net/electronics-lighting-gadgets/)
-   -   Does anybody know a good headlight for the front forks? (http://www.bikeforums.net/electronics-lighting-gadgets/895750-does-anybody-know-good-headlight-front-forks.html)

nans 06-14-13 02:34 PM

Does anybody know a good headlight for the front forks?
 
Im looking for a nice headlight that will mount on either of the forks of my porteur build I've been working on. I have a front rack which makes it more difficult to mount a light off the brake bolt.

Anyone have any good suggestions?

Athens80 06-14-13 06:18 PM

1 Attachment(s)
This quick release mount with a conventional light might accomplish your purpose.
http://bikeforums.net/attachment.php...hmentid=323304

zacster 06-15-13 03:12 PM

There's the MagnicLight. No batteries, no dynohub, no wires. It runs off the magnetic flux created by the spinning wheel, or something like that. It mounts on the fork just off the rim. They have both front and rear versions. It is still pretty new, and I haven't seen many reviews of it, but there is a discussion on Candlepower forums, with a lot of skepticism thrown in. But if it works it works.

no1mad 06-15-13 08:08 PM

You might be better served if you posted a pic or link to your front rack. There may be a way to mount a light to the front of it.

01 CAt Man Do 06-16-13 02:24 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by zacster (Post 15746359)
There's the MagnicLight. No batteries, no dynohub, no wires. It runs off the magnetic flux created by the spinning wheel, or something like that. It mounts on the fork just off the rim. They have both front and rear versions. It is still pretty new, and I haven't seen many reviews of it, but there is a discussion on Candlepower forums, with a lot of skepticism thrown in. But if it works it works.

That's a very interesting light. Certainly worthy enough to have it's own thread. I'd like to see another version of this light with two conducting units ( one on each side of the wheel ) and connected to a separate lamp unit ( via cable/wire ) so you could mount the lamp on the bars. Not to mention I'd like to see a flash mode for daytime use.

I like the set-up as it is right now ( being self contained ) but I have questions to how it gets mounted to the bike. The video didn't really show the bracket used for mounting. Since the lamp is mounted so close to the wheel a good amount of light is lost being blocked by the wheel/tire. I love the concept though.

FlatSix911 06-16-13 03:04 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by zacster (Post 15746359)
There's the MagnicLight. No batteries, no dynohub, no wires. It runs off the magnetic flux created by the spinning wheel, or something like that. It mounts on the fork just off the rim. They have both front and rear versions. It is still pretty new, and I haven't seen many reviews of it, but there is a discussion on Candlepower forums, with a lot of skepticism thrown in. But if it works it works.

Very interesting concept ... I wonder if it works with Carbon wheels?

Edit ... just found this FAQ link http://www.kickstarter.com/projects/...get-new-energy

Quote:

Some details on Magnic Light
•Does Magnic Light need batteries?
- No, the Magnic Light system contains a magnet driven dynamo which needs no batteries.
•Does it work with aluminium wheels?
- Yes, Magnic Light works with all standard wheels except full carbon wheels and it works with all bicycle types.
There is no limit on wheel size, so you can use the same system for small children bikes as well as for MTBs, ATBs, and race bikes.


Burton 06-16-13 07:21 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by FlatSix911 (Post 15749193)
Very interesting concept ... I wonder if it works with Carbon wheels?

Edit ... just found this FAQ link http://www.kickstarter.com/projects/...get-new-energy





Agree the concept looks really interesting. The opening cautionary note in the Operater's Manual leaves me kinda dubious as to it being terribly effective though.
Quote:

The Magnic Light system is intended only for installation with original Magnic Light adapters as additional lighting system (not as a sole source of light!)
So $70 for a single 'be seen' light? Sigh! No sale to this commuter!

zacster 06-16-13 08:12 PM

I think the reason for the disclaimer is that they are not STZVO compliant, and they are a German company. It is more than a "be seen" light, but maybe less than the light cannons we use which may be overkill.

Come to think of it, I haven't seen anything else about them here. Here's one review: http://bike.duque.net/review-the-magnic-lights

I would be willing to try a rear light for $80, but the full setup for $240 is a bit steep.

Burton 06-17-13 07:57 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by zacster (Post 15749994)
I think the reason for the disclaimer is that they are not STZVO compliant, and they are a German company. It is more than a "be seen" light, but maybe less than the light cannons we use which may be overkill.

Come to think of it, I haven't seen anything else about them here. Here's one review: http://bike.duque.net/review-the-magnic-lights

I would be willing to try a rear light for $80, but the full setup for $240 is a bit steep.

Thanks for the link! The rear lights definately look most interesting. Suspect they're not STZVO compliant because there's no stand light built in and no beam cutoff. I did notice that he brought a helmet light as a supplement on his brevet, and that the headlight output wasn't significantly better than a dyno unit.

Still - will probably order a couple rear units to check out. The unlimited runtime / no maintenaince part is certainly nice.

shurin 06-18-13 01:42 AM

3 Attachment(s)
Quote:

Originally Posted by zacster (Post 15746359)
There's the MagnicLight. No batteries, no dynohub, no wires. It runs off the magnetic flux created by the spinning wheel, or something like that. It mounts on the fork just off the rim. They have both front and rear versions. It is still pretty new, and I haven't seen many reviews of it, but there is a discussion on Candlepower forums, with a lot of skepticism thrown in. But if it works it works.

Awesome! Very expensive, though.

As for mounting a light to fork, I made my own:
http://bikeforums.net/attachment.php...hmentid=324052 http://bikeforums.net/attachment.php...hmentid=324053 http://bikeforums.net/attachment.php...hmentid=324054

A piece of aluminum tube cut from a broken frame pump, hose clamp and a vine cork. very secure and weighs almost nothing. Weight weenies can leave out the cork, use zip ties and drill out the tube ;)

chaadster 06-21-13 08:34 PM

I'm not impressed with the Magnic either, and frankly think Reelights (http://shop.reelight.com) provide a better looking, more versatile magnet powered setup, and the hub mounted units offer a solution for the OP.

zacster 06-22-13 04:24 AM

The difference with the Magnic light vs. the Reelight is that the Magnic requires no magnets on the spokes. It is an entirely stand-alone unit and uses the rim to drive it. Both though are looking to do away with the dynamo hub so you can use the wheels you have. The Magnic light also nicely does away with wires.

I have neither though, so I can't say how bright either is, nor whether they would throw a useful beam.

Olsonist 12-01-14 04:49 PM

more differences
 
Other differences between the Magnic light vs. the Reelight are:
Reelight rear is mounted up on the seatpost
Magnic has no wires
Magnic can be "easily" swapped between two bikes
Reelight rear is mounted down on one side of the rim
Reelight weighs more, costs less and is more available

zacster 12-02-14 05:14 AM

I did eventually buy a rear Magnic light. It was very bright for a rear even during the daytime. People would stop me all the time and ask about it. The problem was the mount though and I lost it. I'm getting another one, if Dirk ever gets it all together for his latest kickstarter. He's already 6-7 months late on delivery. The newest one has a standlight, flashes if wanted, uses less power to produce more light by using better Cree LEDs. It is still pretty pricy though, but since I had one I wanted another. My advice though is to NOT order one until he clears his backlog and has them in stock, and that may not be for a long while.

For the front I have a standard Shimano dynamo hub and B&M Cyo premium light. Standard is relative though, these are so rare in the US that I have yet to see another on the road here in bike crazy Brooklyn or Manhattan. The big exception though is Citibike, they all have dynamo hub lighting, except I think the lights are really bad.

JonnyHK 12-02-14 08:17 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by zacster (Post 17355496)
I did eventually buy a rear Magnic light. It was very bright for a rear even during the daytime. People would stop me all the time and ask about it. The problem was the mount though and I lost it. I'm getting another one, if Dirk ever gets it all together for his latest kickstarter. He's already 6-7 months late on delivery. The newest one has a standlight, flashes if wanted, uses less power to produce more light by using better Cree LEDs. It is still pretty pricy though, but since I had one I wanted another. My advice though is to NOT order one until he clears his backlog and has them in stock, and that may not be for a long while.

I got in on the Kickstarter and am still waiting.

Luckily he's put up some more information about his delays so I'm happy to wait since I think the lights will be fantastic when I eventually get them. I do hope he sorts it out because it is a great product.

zacster 12-03-14 06:23 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by JonnyHK (Post 17355723)
I got in on the Kickstarter and am still waiting.

Luckily he's put up some more information about his delays so I'm happy to wait since I think the lights will be fantastic when I eventually get them. I do hope he sorts it out because it is a great product.

He'd be better off if he would at least assemble some units and start shipping, rather than waiting for a large number to be complete.

bikemig 12-03-14 07:16 AM

I'm planning on picking up a cronometro NOB as that allows you to mount a light on any tube of your bike. I'd like to run a light on my front fork when using a front handlebar bag:

Accessories

tarwheel 12-03-14 09:14 AM

1 Attachment(s)
I have made several bike mounts similar to the one posted by Athens80 using PVC pipe fittings from the local Ace Hardware. The cost is less than $2 each. All you need is a short connector and plug. Then I drill a hose in the middle of the plug, just large enough to run a bolt and washer through it. Finally, I bolt the PVC mount to my bike frame. I usually put the PVC mount on one of the rear chainstay rack mounts to hold my Dinotte taillight while commuting. However, I also have used it on the front fork of my touring bike to hold a headlight.

Regarding headlights, I highly recommend the Light & Motion Urban series for a front light mounted to a fork. Not only are they very bright with excellent run times, they are also very compact and light weight. My Urban 800 weighs only about 120 grams.

In the attached photo, you can see the mount on my bike's front fork.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 12:24 PM.