Bike Forums

Bike Forums (http://www.bikeforums.net/forum.php)
-   Fifty Plus (50+) (http://www.bikeforums.net/fifty-plus-50/)
-   -   Cycle computer (http://www.bikeforums.net/fifty-plus-50/232013-cycle-computer.html)

fopianki 09-26-06 12:32 PM

Cycle computer
 
Hi folks, just bought the brand spankin' new Serotta Fierte and I need to get a computer for it. It's been years since I've bought a computer...my Softride has had the same one since 2001. I'd prefer a wireless setup and I'd like the basics (although cadence would also be nice!). Any recommendations on a computer that is user friendly and reliable? Frank

Spoke 09-26-06 12:43 PM

If it has Shimano STI levers, look into the Flight Deck. I love it.

-Spoke

stapfam 09-26-06 12:44 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by fopianki
Hi folks, just bought the brand spankin' new Serotta Fierte and I need to get a computer for it. It's been years since I've bought a computer...my Softride has had the same one since 2001. I'd prefer a wireless setup and I'd like the basics (although cadence would also be nice!). Any recommendations on a computer that is user friendly and reliable? Frank

Have gone through the range of computers on the market and all I want to know is current speed- average speed for the ride and milage. Cadence is somthing that I have on the Tandem but we rarely use taht facility now.

Now with regard to wireless. They can interfere with heart monitors and get interference themselves from other sources. Easy to set up but then something goes out of sync and it stops working till you get it sorted out. A lot to recommend for the conventional wired versions with the BIG worry of breaking wires being non-existant. Have only broken one wired version and as it was a wire break- A quick splice and it was fixed. But the number of times I have had to refit the Wireless versions drives me nuts.

What have I got? An Astrale wired version with cadence on the tandem and the other two are cateye wireless. Or should I say one other is a wireless as I lost the fork sensor last week somewhere up on the hills on the MTB.
So will be following this thread for when I get yet another replacement.

fopianki 09-26-06 01:15 PM

Thanks...so are you saying that your preference is the wired Astrale? I have wireless computers on both mine and my wife's mountain bike and they constantly have to be reset...and they also don't start up automatically when we start riding...you have to push the button. They were cheapo nashbar computers and I always thought it was just the model...but from what you are saying, it may be due to the technology...something to think about...regards Frank

fopianki 09-26-06 01:17 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Spoke
If it has Shimano STI levers, look into the Flight Deck. I love it.

-Spoke

So who makes the Flight Deck...any suggestions as to a website where I can review and possibly purchase it? thanks! Frank

Fredmertz51 09-26-06 01:24 PM

I use a Garmin Forerunner 205 on my wrist. No wires, no programming, no brackets on bike. Figures average speed, calories, distance , maps routes into your computer. Settings for running, biking, and other. Expensive, but works for running, walking, etc. No cadence tho.

Artmo 09-26-06 01:29 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by fopianki
Hi folks, just bought the brand spankin' new Serotta Fierte and I need to get a computer for it. It's been years since I've bought a computer...my Softride has had the same one since 2001. I'd prefer a wireless setup and I'd like the basics (although cadence would also be nice!). Any recommendations on a computer that is user friendly and reliable? Frank

I use a Garmin Forerunner 301 which gives speed, HR, distance, av HR, av speed etc, etc. I like it because I can move it from bike to bike - I have 3 plus the tandem - and only have to strap it to the handlebars.
It does not provide cadence, but the Garmin 305 does, but I assume you have to fit sensors to the bike for this.

leob1 09-26-06 01:35 PM

Have a look at the Cateye Micro, it is wireless. My wife has used one for over a year, it has never failed to start. I have never had to readjust it, or fiddle with it to get it working. Other wire less units from other mfgrs have all had 'issues'.

Spoke 09-26-06 03:17 PM

Shimano makes the Flight Deck. I would assume hundreds of web sites sell it. Just google Shimano Flight Deck. I bought mine from Branford Bike. It was easy to install and I like the "virtual" cadance and the gear indicator. Mine is wireless, just the computer on the handelbar and the transmitter on the fork, no wires, except for the wires under the handlebar tape to the shifters. I have not had any problems with it. Take a look.

-Spoke

Cadillac 09-26-06 04:03 PM

My Cateye wireless on my DF is tempermental.
I have changed the batteries, reset the pickup in relation to the sensor, played with the distance between pickup and head -- but I still have the same problem.
For no reason at all, the speed drops off and becomes erratic.
It might work good for a kilometer, then it skips a few beats.

My "cheepo" wired speedo on my Catrike works flawlessly.

jazzy_cyclist 09-26-06 04:04 PM

I have an Astrale 8 (wired) on one bike. I torqued the zip tie too tight when I first installed it. But since then, I have never had a problem with it. (it has cadence). I think they're about 30-40 bucks these days.

I have a CatEye Wireless on my other bike. It works pretty well, but I think it interferes with my HRM on occasion. It was about 150 IIRC.

My wife has a flight deck and likes it because it shows her which gear she's in, but she also inadvertently resets it from time to time by hitting the wrong button.

brownsfan 09-26-06 06:12 PM

I have a Garmin Edge 305. Since the speed is based on GPS there is no probe to hook up to the bicycle. There are two options available with the Edge 305 -- a heart rate monitor and cadence. Another improvement in the Edge 305 is that altitude is based on a barometric pressure measurement so it is more accurate than altitude based on GPS.

It's a little pricey, but I like it a lot.

Red Baron 09-26-06 06:47 PM

I vote for the Astrale 8 also. Had a flight Deck - but I kept inadvertently turning it on off. Especially when climbing hills. Kind of neat though- to see what gears you are in.

cyclintom 09-26-06 07:29 PM

I've used just about EVERY cycle computer on the market and most of them work OK for awhile and then fail one way or another. The only one I've had that doesn't seem to fail is the Cateye models. Though that might simply be a freak.

I used to have Avocets on all of my bikes but as soon as you replaced the battery they wouldn't work after awhile. Lately I put SIGS on all my bikes and they worked very good for about 8 months and then three of them started showing "miles" but reading "kilometers per hour". Reseting had no effect.

Avenir as well stopped working for no apparent reasons. Vetta worked OK but then they got to be hard to find.

The Cateye seems to just keep on working though. But I'd bet as soon as I put them on everything they'll all quit at once.

jwbnyc 09-26-06 07:39 PM

I ditched mine.

SteveE 09-26-06 09:05 PM

OK, screw the wireless, suck it up, and just get a Cateye Astrale.

(Yes, Dnvrfox, I broke my self-imposed rule not to post on the silly 50+ forum.)


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 06:18 AM.