Bike Forums

Bike Forums (http://www.bikeforums.net/forum.php)
-   Framebuilders (http://www.bikeforums.net/framebuilders/)
-   -   Custom Steel Roadie (http://www.bikeforums.net/framebuilders/864372-custom-steel-roadie.html)

Wheels Of Steel 12-26-12 01:19 PM

Custom Steel Roadie
 
Seems most custom framebuilders charge upwards of $1900-$2500 for their entry-level road frameset. Why don't more people go through Mercian and have them build a custom frame shipped to the US for ~$1600 using Reynolds 631?

Specs I'm looking for:

700x28c w/fenders
Audax geo
Reynolds 631 or equivalent

marqueemoon 12-26-12 01:55 PM

Not all.

In my region Curtlo and Elephant are fairly affordable options.

It really comes down to what you want aesthetically. Fancy lugs and wet paint are nice and all, but don't matter a bit in how a frame fits and rides.

fietsbob 12-26-12 04:56 PM

If you just want different fittings and are really using a standard sized frame, the options multiply.

calstar 12-26-12 08:47 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by marqueemoon (Post 15088966)
Not all.

In my region Curtlo and Elephant are fairly affordable options.

It really comes down to what you want aesthetically. Fancy lugs and wet paint are nice and all, but don't matter a bit in how a frame fits and rides.

+1 I have a Curtlo, great bike, Ox Platinum tubing. He sells road frame(fillet brazed) and fork for $1300 +-, one of the best deals going for a custom frame. You can also get build/component packages at a very good price. Here's the link:

http://www.curtlo.com/pricing.html

unterhausen 12-26-12 09:45 PM

I think Mercian makes fairly pedestrian looking bikes. If I was set on getting a discount custom frame, I would probably get a Gunnar or go through one of many companies selling waterfords that they have designed themselves.

Globallyoff 12-26-12 10:56 PM

i would try and buy American if I could first. Having said that, Mercian offers many bikes that are not "pedestrian" such aa a Vincintore. They have been in the framebuilding businesss a long time and tend to turn out a good product at a good price.

marqueemoon 12-27-12 01:36 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by calstar (Post 15090371)
+1 I have a Curtlo, great bike, Ox Platinum tubing. He sells road frame(fillet brazed) and fork for $1300 +-, one of the best deals going for a custom frame. You can also get build/component packages at a very good price. Here's the link:

http://www.curtlo.com/pricing.html

Yeah.

I'm looking to do a build similar to what the OP has in mind, but maybe a little sportier. Curtlo is definitely on the list as is Elephant.
Both do single color powdercoat as the standard finish.

Here are some semi-custom options maybe the OP hasn't thought of.

Box Dog Pelican (built by Eric at Winter) such a hot frame and fork! Incredible value if you ask me if the geometry works and you can deal with the Henry Ford approach to paint color.
http://shop.boxdogbikes.com/collecti...pelican-winter

Boulder Bicycle randonneur (Waterford-built)
http://www.renehersebicycles.com/Randonneur%20bikes.htm

Milwaukee road frame (Ben's Cycle - Waterford built) available in OX Platinum and with a Waterford-built fork for an upcharge
http://www.benscycle.net/index.php?m...cPath=612_2235

triathloner 12-27-12 08:00 AM

I believe that Ben's imports from overseas their frames and paints them here. I could be wrong on that but that is what I remember from some research a while back. Ben's is a great store if you ever get a chance to visit. Very helpful people, pretty good prices on a lot of items.

Scooper 12-27-12 09:31 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by triathloner (Post 15091205)
I believe that Ben's imports from overseas their frames and paints them here. I could be wrong on that but that is what I remember from some research a while back. Ben's is a great store if you ever get a chance to visit. Very helpful people, pretty good prices on a lot of items.

This description of the Milwaukee Road Bike is copied and pasted from the Ben's website:

Quote:

Originally Posted by Ben's Cycle website
Features and Information:
Frame is made in the USA by Waterford Precision Cycles!*
• Built with True Temper OX Platinum Tubing!
• Designed for use as a geared road or cyclocross bike
• Set-up for a long reach (47-57mm) brakes
• Down Tube Shifter Bosses!
• Chainstay Bridge
• Down tube AND Seat tube mounted water bottle braze-on.
• High quality Ritchey road dropouts!
• Seatpost Clamp Included!
• Designed to fit up to a 700x32c tire - take it Cyclocrossing if you wish!
• 1-/8" head tube, 27.2mm seatpost, 130mm rear spacing, 68mm bottom bracket shell.
*The frame is made by Waterford, but the fork is not. The fork is a standard road fork we import. Waterford upgrade available below for added cost.


marqueemoon 12-27-12 11:14 AM

Like it says above the standard fork is imported (looks like the Surly Pacer fork to me), but you can pay a little more and get a Waterford built fork.

FYI they will do braze-ons for Paul Racer/Racer Mediums for the same upcharge as canti bosses. At least this is what I was told when I asked about it.

Wheels Of Steel 12-27-12 12:43 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by marqueemoon (Post 15090935)
Yeah.

I'm looking to do a build similar to what the OP has in mind, but maybe a little sportier. Curtlo is definitely on the list as is Elephant.
Both do single color powdercoat as the standard finish.

Here are some semi-custom options maybe the OP hasn't thought of.

Box Dog Pelican (built by Eric at Winter) such a hot frame and fork! Incredible value if you ask me if the geometry works and you can deal with the Henry Ford approach to paint color.
http://shop.boxdogbikes.com/collecti...pelican-winter

Boulder Bicycle randonneur (Waterford-built)
http://www.renehersebicycles.com/Randonneur%20bikes.htm

Milwaukee road frame (Ben's Cycle - Waterford built) available in OX Platinum and with a Waterford-built fork for an upcharge
http://www.benscycle.net/index.php?m...cPath=612_2235

Am familiar with all three. The BDBP and BBR are rando frames. I'm currently more interested in an audax-style road frame.

Gunnars are appealing. Built by Waterford with a more modern design when compared to Mercian. What's an average ball-park price difference between Gunnar and Waterford full custom framesets? How much extra is it typically to add a set of eyelets to a fork? I'm having difficulty finding this information on either of their websites.

EDIT

Just spent more time reading the literature on Gunnar's site. They use either True Temper OX Platinum or Reynolds 853 tubes, yes? My understanding of "higher grade" steel alloys is that while they are admittedly lighter they aren't as durable as a heavier, "lower grade" steel e.g. Reynolds 631. Perhaps I'm oversimplifying, or just outright misunderstanding?

tuz 12-27-12 07:54 PM

In Canada there is also Marinoni that offers custom frames (mostly road "race") at a pretty good price.

unterhausen 12-28-12 02:43 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Wheels Of Steel (Post 15092232)
Am familiar with all three. The BDBP and BBR are rando frames. I'm currently more interested in an audax-style road frame.

that's a pretty fine distinction, what is the difference in your mind? Audax has less trail because the rides are fully supported and there is less reason for a handlebar bag?

Quote:

Originally Posted by Wheels Of Steel (Post 15092232)

Just spent more time reading the literature on Gunnar's site. They use either True Temper OX Platinum or Reynolds 853 tubes, yes? My understanding of "higher grade" steel alloys is that while they are admittedly lighter they aren't as durable as a heavier, "lower grade" steel e.g. Reynolds 631. Perhaps I'm oversimplifying, or just outright misunderstanding?

higher grade steels are better. The only reason you might worry about that is if you don't trust your builder and the cheaper steel comes in thicker tubes. I would find a better builder.

Andrew R Stewart 12-28-12 08:03 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by unterhausen (Post 15095756)
that's a pretty fine distinction, what is the difference in your mind? Audax has less trail because the rides are fully supported and there is less reason for a handlebar bag?


higher grade steels are better. The only reason you might worry about that is if you don't trust your builder and the cheaper steel comes in thicker tubes. I would find a better builder.

Eric- I thought that the current craze with low trail geometry was to work better with front loads (handle bar bags). Set me straight (as George Bailey said). I agree that thinner walled tubing is more sensitive to the bumps and dings of daily life let alone the sensitivity of brazing skills. Andy.

unterhausen 12-28-12 10:39 PM

Audax is a form of randonneuring where the riders are all together. Unless you live in the UK, where they don't seem to make the distinction. The OP seemed to be saying he didn't want a randonneuring bike, preferring an Audax bike, and I have never heard a distinction made.

If someone says "rando bike" to me nowadays, I expect it to be low trail. But not really because most randonneurs ride such a bike.

Wheels Of Steel 12-29-12 11:41 AM

Finer grade steels are more brittle, no? Durability is critical.

http://velo-orange.blogspot.com/2012...-is-steel.html

"Thin-wall tubing is very easy to dent. That's why we wouldn't recommend it for a commuting bike or a touring bike. It's also more likely to be destroyed in a crash, even a mild one. That high end thin-wall tubing may be okay for racing bikes, but you must still be careful with them."

unterhausen 12-29-12 02:41 PM

denting is not indicative of brittleness and they didn't say it was. Yes, if you routinely knock your bike around, a thicker tube is better. But in normal usage, a better grade of steel is less likely to have a ductile failure due to overloads or some shortcoming in construction. You can go overboard on the weight-weenieism, but for road use a high grade steel in .7/.4/.7 butts is plenty strong enough for everything I do to it. If you are worried about denting, .9/.6/.9 is common in mountain biking, so you can generally find better steels in those thicknesses.

bargainguy 12-29-12 07:49 PM

I have a Gunnar Crosshairs (older, with Reynolds 853) and think it's a smokin' deal. Where else can you get a new high-quality steel frame only (stock, no fork) for less than $1K? In my neck of the woods (WI), it's a precious little secret that drives many locals to make a pilgrimage to Waterford.

Wheels Of Steel 12-29-12 10:20 PM

Thanks for the help everyone.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 12:21 AM.