Specialized Sirrus vs. Trek 7.3fx vs. Gary Fisher Wingra
I've pretty much narrowed it down to these 3 & am leaning towards Specialized.... I believe they are all around the $500 range.
which is the best overall & why? |
Whichever feels better to you. Have you ridden any/all of them?
|
I liked the Sirrus & Gary Fisher the best...test rode them this week..
the 09 sirrus is $20 bucks less than the Gary Fisher but it has grip shifts, which were not so great. The Wingra probably felt best overall. Opinions on the Wingra? good? bad? |
I've ridden an '07 Wingra, it seemed like a fine bike. I am not a big fan of grip shifters either.
|
just picked up my trek 7.3fx 2 weeks ago. love it! been riding it everyday without any problems.
|
I actually meant to put 7.2fx b/c the 7.3fx is in a whole different price range..well $120 more than the wingra & $150 more than the 7.2fx.
the guy at the LBS told me the wingra was a better bike than 7.3fx and cheaper, so to go w/ that...basically saying the components were better on it. |
i actually just bought both a 7.3 and 7.2...
got the 2009 7.3 for 560 and a 2008 7.2 for 440. both not bad bikes at all. |
Although the people around here who have the Wingra don't post much about it, the general impression is that they are pleased with the bike. FWIW, I test rode one back in April or so, and would have bought it if I had cash at the time. I don't need another bike, but if one comes around for a deal, I'll probably buy it.
|
You might be comparing the '09 Trek prices to the wingra's '08 price. For '08, the 7.3 should only be $50 or so more. The Wingra does not have better components than the 7.3 from what I can see. Some are the same/essentially the same, some are worse. For sure the rear derailleur is a couple steps up and I liked the 7.3's shifters better.
If you can budget it and haven't ridden it, give the 7.3 a chance. It is noticeably better than the 7.2 (was to me anyway) and it is getting to be the time of year for discounts. Or just get the Wingra and be happy. |
wingra is $520
7.3fx is $640 |
Again, I don't beleive GF has released '09 prices. Trek has and that is what you are quoting on their end.
'08 wingra $520. '09 Wingra $TBD. '08 7.3 FX $570. -'09 7.3 FX $640. Prices are generally going up in '09, by a noticeable amount for the same model/equipment. Are you getting your prices from a bike shop or from the manufacturers websites? If from bike shops, maybe look around for anoher Trek dealer to see if they have any '08's left...or forget it. |
gary fisher pricing has been released & the 09 bikes are on teh website as well..... it's $520
|
Sorry, my mistake...I would still look around for '08's
|
Originally Posted by tdister
(Post 7457184)
Sorry, my mistake...I would still look around for '08's
|
I would guess they don't make/sell very many. I've only ever seen one in Austin and the one I rode in Dallas. Good luck.
I just noticed they changed up the Trek's FX line for '09. Wonder how different they ride? |
Originally Posted by tdister
(Post 7459462)
I just noticed they changed up the Trek's FX line for '09. Wonder how different they ride?
I just looked at the '09 FX line on the web and it looks like Trek has lightened up the frame. They likely made a good bike even better. If you haven't already bought a bike it might be worth your time to see if you can find an '08 7.3 to test drive and save some $$$. |
All times are GMT -6. The time now is 09:25 AM. |
Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.