Bike Forums

Bike Forums (http://www.bikeforums.net/forum.php)
-   General Cycling Discussion (http://www.bikeforums.net/general-cycling-discussion/)
-   -   Pedals, Best bang for the buck?? (http://www.bikeforums.net/general-cycling-discussion/588813-pedals-best-bang-buck.html)

dennisa 09-26-09 09:32 PM

Pedals, Best bang for the buck??
 
e.g. Most would say for bikes the Caad9 is the best bang for the buck. I'm looking for a similar suggestion in regards to pedals.

From searching the forums I see the popular choices are Look Keo, Shimano SPD-SL, and Speedplay. Are pedals something that are more user specific. e.g. Someone might ride with Look Keo's and never get hotspots etc... yet someone else might use them and experience hot spots.

Overall which pedal am I going to buy and not need to change for many years to come. I'd rather not buy a set of pedals for say $80, to find they aren't worth is only to spend a little more on a second set, When I could of just spent a little more up front on a better pedal and be done with it.

stapfam 09-27-09 12:43 AM

Depends on the style of shoe. If MTB- then go for Shimano SPD shoes and pedals. The small area of cleat/ pedal interface can cause a hot spot on some combinations but I use the the standard MTB pedal in the M520 on most of my bikes. However when I went road- I had the hotspot come in. Went for the A520 instead and this has a longer pedal platform for the foot. Works for me and cheap.

canopus 09-27-09 08:14 AM

For the road bike I have been using the Nashbar Ventoux 2 for a little over 2000 miles so far since March. no complaints here and they don't break the bank like some of the others and are fully Look compatible. No hotspots with my Shimano R80 shoes either. My Saturday rides are between 70 and 100 miles and my weekly rides are around 30 to 45. Best $35 I have spent.

Bianchigirll 09-27-09 09:18 AM

I was a dedicated LOOK fan (the orginal not SPD style) until a few years ago, but went to shimano spd. but recently I have switched most of my bikes to this Wellgo from Bianchi. I like the bigger overall platform as it makes starting out at stopssigns and lights easier, I can just put my foot down and go. the double sided is also a big bonous as I do not have to worry about which side is up or turning the pedal to clip in. at $46 they may not be 'best bang for the buck' but they get the job done. and the color is not bad either.

https://www.bianchiusa.com/store/sho...181/parts.html

estabro 09-27-09 05:11 PM

If you like SPD-SL's then the Ultegra's are a good choice,

PaulRivers 09-28-09 02:03 PM

If you're not racing, Speedplay Light Action ($125) pedals are right at that point. Apparently some of the racers like to have more tension for release, but for most of us they're fantastic and models above that are exponentially more expensive for slightly less weight.

If you are racing, or whatever, some people prefer the Zero's. Apparently they don't unclip quite as easy as the light actions, which the racers and regular riders prefer. I haven't tried them though, so I cannot comment on how big the difference is.

So I would go with the Speedplay Light Action's or the Speedplay Zero's. I would avoid the Speedplay X-Series - I have them, and they're really susceptible to getting clogged up with dirt. Apparently the plastic piece in the other two models keeps dirt from getting into the moving spring (I'm seriously considering the light actions myself right now to replace them).

Speedplays are great pedals because they're dual sided (no looking down or flipping over the pedal at intersections or when getting on and off the bike) and they have good amount of float (let's the back of your foot rotate, usually easier on your knees).

I assumed you're looking for a road pedal due to your mention of the caad9. If you're looking for a mountain bike pedal, that's a whole 'nother topic.

Robert Foster 09-28-09 05:00 PM

Pedals are a bit like saddles in that there are many different styles people like and dislike. I have some time attack pedals that I had on all of my bikes for about a year and a half. They work well will MTB shoes and because I like to walk around a bit on some of my rides that is what I prefer. I had some speed play pedals that were light and were easy to get in and out of but they required a road shoe and a cafť cover to walk in. Speed plays hate getting dirty and don’t like to clip in if you get anything in them. I ended up trading the speed plays for some crank brother’s egg beaters. Some of my friends told me they didn’t care for egg beaters but with stiff soled MTB shoes I haven’t had a problem with hot spots on 75 mile rides. I’ll know more after this weekend’s Century. But I have Time Attack on my MTB and egg beaters on my road bike because both are easy to use even if you get the cleats dirty.

Tapeworm21 09-28-09 05:23 PM

Look Keo Sprints is what I like. Shimano's are pretty sweet too, but I like the entry of a Look pedal better. Speedplay on the other hand... no spanks.

dennisa 09-28-09 08:04 PM

Yes, you'd be correct, I'm looking for a road pedal.

PaulRivers 09-28-09 11:05 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Robert Foster (Post 9760847)
Pedals are a bit like saddles in that there are many different styles people like and dislike. I have some time attack pedals that I had on all of my bikes for about a year and a half. They work well will MTB shoes and because I like to walk around a bit on some of my rides that is what I prefer. I had some speed play pedals that were light and were easy to get in and out of but they required a road shoe and a cafť cover to walk in. Speed plays hate getting dirty and donít like to clip in if you get anything in them. I ended up trading the speed plays for some crank brotherís egg beaters. Some of my friends told me they didnít care for egg beaters but with stiff soled MTB shoes I havenít had a problem with hot spots on 75 mile rides. Iíll know more after this weekendís Century. But I have Time Attack on my MTB and egg beaters on my road bike because both are easy to use even if you get the cleats dirty.

Quote:

So I would go with the Speedplay Light Action's or the Speedplay Zero's. I would avoid the Speedplay X-Series - I have them, and they're really susceptible to getting clogged up with dirt. Apparently the plastic piece in the other two models keeps dirt from getting into the moving spring (I'm seriously considering the light actions myself right now to replace them).
Related. Just saying. :-)


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 10:16 PM.