I am 6'2" with about a 34 inch inseam and the 60 was too big for me! I ride a 58 now!
Also, I road a 1995 Schwinn for 14 years before I bought my Madone. I was never fitted to the Schwinn, and when I started shopping for a high end bike, and was fitted, I found the Schwinn was not the right size bike for me.
But over 14 yrs of ridding the wrong size bike, my body adapted to it ( not a good thing). Then when I test road bikes that were the right size, they felt awkward.
Well, I took the advise of my dealer, and bought the Madone. They were willing to give me 30 days to ride it and make sure it was the one for me! It felt funny for a little while, but hands stop falling asleep, my butt and back did not bother me on real long rides and the rest is history!
I now feel at one with my ride!
I hope this info helps..It sure helped me!