Advertise on Bikeforums.net



User Tag List

Results 1 to 4 of 4
  1. #1
    Absorbent Newcomer ScooTrikkeBike's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2010
    Location
    Walla Walla, WA
    My Bikes
    21" Motobecane 700HT 26" MTN w/ Thudbuster LT (in the mail), Mongoose DXR-AL 24" Full Sus., Roadmaster Navigator Mt 26" mtn.
    Posts
    14
    Mentioned
    0 Post(s)
    Tagged
    0 Thread(s)

    Forge Sawback 5xx vs. Motobecane 700HT?

    A little while ago I posted a thread inquiring about good full suspension bikes, but decided to look for a decent Hardtail instead. I was planning on just buying the Forge Sawback 5xx because it has decent components, but after taxes and shipping combined, the unbeatable $379 becomes about $440.

    I was just surfing the web and came across bikesdirect.com. I didn't really make much of it, but saw that they had several bikes for sale at really good prices within my range and with decent specs. I was actually planning on just flat out buying their Windsor 4900 because I saw that it had very good reviews and it was only $399, but they are out of stock for it.

    Anyways, I couldn't buy that, so I thought about the Motobecane 700HT. since bikesdirect doesn't have shipping or tax, the $499 price tag wasn't as bad is the $379 price tag of the Sawback.

    Here are the spec differences:

    Forge Sawback 5xx:

    Size: 19" FRAME / STANDOVER HEIGHT 31.7"
    Color: MATTE BLUE / SILVER
    Frame: 6061 ALL ALUMINUM, DOUBLE-BUTTED, HYDROFORMED GUSSET, WITH DISC AND RACK/ FENDER MOUNTS
    Front Suspension: ROCKSHOX DART 1 W/ADJUSTABLE PRELOAD, 100MM TRAVEL
    Wheels
    Rims: WTB SPEEDDISC, 32-HOLE
    Hubs: JOYTECH ALLOY QR DISC 32H
    Spokes: 14G STAINLESS STEEL
    Tires: ITS NINJA 26X2.1"
    Drivetrain
    Speed: 27
    Shifters: SHIMANO DEORE
    Front Derailleur: SHIMANO ALIVIO
    Rear Derailleur: SHIMANO DEORE
    Crankset: TRUVATIV ISOFLOW ALUMINUM TRIPLE 22/32/42T
    Bottom Bracket: VP SEALED CARTRIDGE
    Cassete: SRAM PG950, 34-11T, 9 SPEED
    Chain: SHIMANO HG73
    Pedals: ALLOY PLATFORM
    Components
    Saddle: WTB PURE V SPORT
    Seat Post: ALLOY 30.8X350MM, ADJUST WITH QUICK RELEASE
    Handlebar: MTB-ALLOY 30MM RISE
    Stem: FORGE-ALLOY 105MM
    Grips: WTB TRAIL
    Brake Set: AVID BB-5, MECHANICAL DISC
    Brake Levers: TEKTRO ALLOY
    Extras: PRESTA VALVES, CATEYE REFLECTOR SET, TWO WATER BOTTLE MOUNTS, STORAGE RACK & FENDER MOUNTS CLEAR COAT PAINT FINISH AND OWNERS MANUAL

    Motobecane 700HT:

    Frame Custom 7005 Aluminum Trail-Tuned POWER STAY frame, box section chainstays, bi-axial gussetted downtube, sculpted rear dropouts with replaceable rear derailleur hanger, 2x H2O bosses, International Standard rear disc mounts Detailed Picture Gallery
    Fork RockShox Dart 2 Adjustable with Advanced LockOut (crown-mount lever)
    Crankset TruVativ 5D Aluminum Triple 22/32/42T 175mm (TruShift Rings)
    Bottom Bracket Sealed Cartridge
    Pedals ATB Beartrap (metal cages)
    Front Derailleur Shimano Deore Mega 9 top swing
    Rear Derailleur Shimano Deore XT long cage
    Shifters Shimano Deore Mega 9 Speed STI Rapidfire Pods (27 speeds total)
    Cassette/Freewheel Cassette 11-32T 9 Speed Hyperglide
    Chain 9 Speed Z9000 Super Narrow
    Hubs Formula DiscSpecific Aluminum (black) Sealed Ball Bearing mechanism
    Spokes Stainless Steel
    Rims WTB SpeedDisc Rims Double Wall Aluminum
    Tires WTB Velociraptor Blackwall 26 x 2.10
    Brakes

    Mechanical Disc Brakes with Multi Pad Angle adjustments
    (Note: Brakes are Tektro Aquila or Avid BB5, No Choice)
    Brake Levers Tektro for Disc
    Headset Cane Creek Internal Sealed caged ball bearing VP A42E 1.125 inch
    Handlebar Skye Comp Aluminum Riser
    Stem Skye Comp Threadless Aluminum
    Tape/Grip WTB Dual Compound
    Saddle WTB Speed V with comfort groove
    Seat Post Skye Aluminum Micro-Adjust
    Seat Clamp Alloy w/QR
    Sizes 15, 17, 19, 21, 23 inch
    Colors Polished Silver Detailed Picture Gallery


    From what the specs show, it seems like the 700HT is a substantially better deal because of the Deore XT versus plain Deore and no Alvio components etc., but I am not sure if anyone knows which one will most likely be better based on the components (because I have heard that they are both well made). I only have $450, but I am willing to wait a week or two to buy the 700HT if it is a better deal (I currently ride a crappy Mongoose full suspension kids bike and I am 6', 255 lbs)

    I am not sure if the frames would be the same size because the Sawback has a 31.7" standover height while the 700HT has a 30" standover for the 19" model (their 21" is out of stock). I have a foot to crotch measurement of about 33" from what I got when I measured two nights ago, so I am just hoping the 700HT wouldn't be too small if it is the better deal (although since my current bike has a 13" frame anything would fit better).

    As far as modifications go, I am not planning on doing much. I am not an extreme mountain biker, but stuck would like to get the best value and components possible for my budget. My only plan was to put a Cane Creek Thudbuster Suspension Post on it when I get the money (I would have to figure out the post size of the 700HT to find out whether I would need a shim or not, but the skye post is the only thing I have heard complaints about so far) since I really do not like the feel of a hardtail, but like the design. My only concern is whether the Thudbuster post would make either bike fit to tall or too short for me if the 19" stock post is fine.

    Also, if anyone knows of a bike with better components for $500 max, shipped and taxes included (Washington Taxes), I would appreciate to know as well.
    It's as easy as riding a bike...badly

  2. #2
    in luv with two wheels On Any Sunday's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 2008
    Location
    San Diego, California
    My Bikes
    2007 Trek 4300
    Posts
    8
    Mentioned
    0 Post(s)
    Tagged
    0 Thread(s)
    The Sawback's frame tops out at 19.5 inches. They do not offer it in a 21" frame size.

    Question to Forge: Because of that you're losing sales to other manufacturers who accommodate taller people by offering a 21" frame. You've been making this mistake, the same mistake, for years. What is the person at the top of your marketing department thinking?
    Last edited by On Any Sunday; 03-05-11 at 09:41 AM.

  3. #3
    Pants are for suckaz HandsomeRyan's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2007
    Location
    Mt. Airy, MD
    My Bikes
    Hardtail MTB, Fixed gear, and Commuter bike
    Posts
    2,579
    Mentioned
    0 Post(s)
    Tagged
    0 Thread(s)
    Go with the Motobecane. If you aren't confident you can get everything assembled and adjusted properly take it to a shop or have a bike-savvy friend help you.

    Pedal on!

  4. #4
    Absorbent Newcomer ScooTrikkeBike's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2010
    Location
    Walla Walla, WA
    My Bikes
    21" Motobecane 700HT 26" MTN w/ Thudbuster LT (in the mail), Mongoose DXR-AL 24" Full Sus., Roadmaster Navigator Mt 26" mtn.
    Posts
    14
    Mentioned
    0 Post(s)
    Tagged
    0 Thread(s)

    I completely forgot to update...

    Well, thank you all for you posts. I kind of forgot about this thread...

    I ended up getting the Motobecane. It didn't seem too tricky, but just to be safe, I had my local shop assemble it. The $50 was pretty steep, but at least I know it was set up well.

    The bike rides really well and I am glad I went with the 21" frame because it lets me stretch out a bit more. I actually felt like something was wrong when I first mounted it because I was used to my 13" frame on the little children's bike I've been riding.

    I might have the rear derailleur adjusted a bit because it is making a small noise when I pedal, but I was lucky enough to get the ones shipped out with the Avid disc brakes, not the Tektro Aquila, as well as get a well set Dart II fork.

    Anyways, I am pretty happy with my new bike, and although I retired it for the winter (which was pretty brutal, and I'm not quite ready for "blizzard biking" yet), it should be back on the road again (just have to fix my first flat tire on my new bike.)
    It's as easy as riding a bike...badly

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •