Bike Forums

Bike Forums (https://www.bikeforums.net/forum.php)
-   General Cycling Discussion (https://www.bikeforums.net/general-cycling-discussion/)
-   -   Entry/Mid-level Bike Computer - help me decide (https://www.bikeforums.net/general-cycling-discussion/830230-entry-mid-level-bike-computer-help-me-decide.html)

Koobazaur 07-06-12 10:11 AM

Entry/Mid-level Bike Computer - help me decide
 
I ride my Escape 2.0 Hybrid and its about time to get a bike comp! Now I don't care (yet) about super fancy features like heart rate monitors or extraterrestial life detectors, and just want some basic and mid-range stuff, mainly:

* Standard stuff like Travel distance, speed, average speed, max speed, odometer (same as RPM?). And accuracy (should that even be a concern, tho?)
* Automatic stop/start cause I hit a lot of red lights
* Optional-but-Desired: Separating between "current trip" and "total" for the above values would be nice
* Optional-but-Desired: Current Temperature and Time
* BONUS: Current incline grade (that is not GPS-tracked but just a gyro type thing) - I haven't seen any lower-end comps have that, tho, so I doubt ill get it.

Now I DONT want:
* Calories Burn (grossly inaccurate and I dont need to shed pounds)
* HR monitor (dont want anything strapping to my chest, and not that OCD about my "zones")
* GPS (I usually look up my routes pre/post the ride, and it just adds a lot of extra cost)
* Wireless is unneeded, I had wired one and it didnt bother me and is significantly cheaper.

What I am considering and would appreciate your feedback:
* Cadence - how exactly is it measured and how "useful" would it be for me? Is it effectively just RPM? I am not a training/pro/race cyclist, so I don't think I'd care for it.
* Hooking up to my PC / Bluetooth - I guess I could use that to export my times and averages? But since I don't care for GPS tracking I dont see much value in this. Am I wrong?

I use to have this bike comp way way back, which is a surprisingly cheap comp that comes with almost all of my desired functionality. However I figured I might invest in something a wee bit more advanced to see if I care for the extra features (cadence, trip vs. total, temperate etc.)

So far I researched SIGMA and really liked Sigma BC 1609 as it comes with cadence and temp monitors. How is the CADENCE variation of that model? I dont care for the STS one since, as I said, is wireless. The lower models seemed a little lacking in features, and the higher ones had too much stuff I didnt need not warranting the price hike.

What about other companies like Cateye CC-VL810 or Ventura IV? I haven't really researched them as much as Sigma so don't know what the "equivalent" models are, and how they might suit my needs.

Thanks for advice!

late 07-06-12 10:17 AM

Planet Bike 5.0

Nightshade 07-06-12 10:25 AM

I run two Cateye computers. I find them to be just enough to meet my needs being easy to use, easy to install, sturdy.

Mine.....
http://www.amazon.com/Cateye-CC-VL51...+bike+computer

One you're looking at......( I think you'll like it a bunch !! )
http://www.amazon.com/Cateye-CC-VL81...-2147483553-20

rebel1916 07-06-12 11:32 AM

Cadence is nice to have. Check out the Sette branded Pricepoint options. They are bang for buck.

ctimrun2012 07-06-12 10:08 PM

Don't skimp on the alien detector. They will ride right up behind you...and we all know what happens next...

jeffpoulin 07-06-12 10:28 PM


Originally Posted by ctimrun2012 (Post 14449797)
Don't skimp on the alien detector. They will ride right up behind you...and we all know what happens next...

Gang probed?

I like cateyes. The enduros are tough and accurate. The mity 8s are cheaper, but good too.

catonec 07-07-12 02:06 AM

cadence is probably not going to benefit you much in stop and go traffic. I think its meant more for longer trips to help regulate energy spent so you can pace yourself, atleast thats how I use it. plus I think (could be wrong) that cadence computers are wireless.

Id suggest buying any old bike comp as they all are going to display, time, distance, and speed.

with that all said, I have a vetta vl100 on one bike and a cateye strata double on another(both w/cadence). I like them both but the vetta is slightly nicer imo

daven1986 07-07-12 02:09 AM

I'd get a wired blackburn computer that has all the functions you need. I've been very happy with mine which had cadence. However on my road bike at the moment I have a cheap wired ADO computer which has served very well through all types of weather and does speed and distance etc. which is all I really need.

Daven

rebel1916 07-07-12 04:13 PM

I just realized we are all numbskulls. If you don't care about cadence and HR, just get one of the many apps for your phone (Strava, My Tracks etc., try a few and see which work best for you) and one of those brackets to hold your phone on bar or stem. No expense except the bracket and you are good to go with all sorts of cool metrics you can upload to your computer and futz over.

TrekmanDan 07-07-12 09:32 PM

Get the Planet Bike 9.0. It pretty much has everything you need and it's affordable priced. One of the reasons why I like it is because it has a lot of information on one screen, so you don't have to keep toggling to see what you want...

http://www.rei.com/product/786490/pl...-bike-computer

daven1986 07-08-12 03:07 AM


Originally Posted by TrekmanDan (Post 14452751)
Get the Planet Bike 9.0. It pretty much has everything you need and it's affordable priced. One of the reasons why I like it is because it has a lot of information on one screen, so you don't have to keep toggling to see what you want...

http://www.rei.com/product/786490/pl...-bike-computer

Same with the blackburn - lots of information on one screen. It is nice, however when I'm riding I only really care about speed, as I know the distance (I commute).


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 09:37 PM.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.