Bike Forums

Bike Forums (http://www.bikeforums.net/forum.php)
-   General Cycling Discussion (http://www.bikeforums.net/general-cycling-discussion/)
-   -   Difference between 'Dutch' and 'English 3spd' bikes? (http://www.bikeforums.net/general-cycling-discussion/838526-difference-between-dutch-english-3spd-bikes.html)

no1mad 08-10-12 05:52 PM

Difference between 'Dutch' and 'English 3spd' bikes?
 
What exactly are the differences or the primary difference? They both have relaxed geometry and rather upright riding position, correct?

Feel free to point out the modern examples that can be had here in the States today.

rebel1916 08-10-12 06:23 PM

I always think of Dutch bikes as being heavy and English bikes as being light. But this is a completely uninformed opinion.

ahsposo 08-10-12 06:29 PM

The chain guard and the weight and the practical no BS nature of Dutch bikes.

Not sexy but they are every day bikes.

Not that I have any real knowledge of the subject at hand. I sorta made that up.

no1mad 08-10-12 07:48 PM

So the KHS Green would be more like a 'Dutch' bike, while the Felt Cafe 3 would be more like the English 3spd?

conradpdx 08-10-12 09:21 PM

"Dutch" is a more relaxed riding position with a lower seat position and the handle bars set higher. English 3 speed has a slightly more aggressive position higher seat position, low hand position. Yes we aren't talking much, but it's a difference.

A Dutch

http://www.linusbike.com/wp-content/...eam_detail.jpg

An English

http://www.linusbike.com/wp-content/...ssic_black.jpg

I should note that both bikes pictured above are made by Linus.

Dutch also usually comes with all accessories fenders, bell, lights. chain guard, skirt guard...etc. English 3 speeds were mostly just bike and fenders and chain guard. Of course there were exceptions (like the Superbe). But on the whole this would apply.



Of course the obvisous answer is the English bike were made in England, and the Dutch bike made in Dutchlandia.

alhedges 08-10-12 09:32 PM

There are different kinds of English 3 speeds. The Raleigh Tourist is quite similar to a Dutch bike, having a similarly slack seat tube.

Note: today when people talk about slack seat tubes, they typically mean a seat tube angle of 71-72 degrees (as opposed to the angle of 73-75 typically used in racing bikes). Dutch bikes (and the Tourist) have a seat tube angle of 65-67 degrees...maybe that is "extra slack." I think the weight is about the same (45 -50 lbs). The Dutch bike may have higher handlebars, but I'm not sure.

The Raleigh Sport has a seat tube angle of 70-72 degrees and weighs 35-40 lbs. I think it's made of cro-moly steel rather than hi-ten; so it's substantially lighter.

MichaelW 08-11-12 01:50 AM

Different wheel size.
Dutch has Sachs hub, English has Sturmey Archer
Dutch bike has a single rear hub brake, English has F/R rod-operated stirrup brakes.
Dutch have built-in bike stand for leaving outside schpecial coffee schop, English bikes are leant against the tobacconist shop window.
Dutch rear racks are stronger for carrying svelte and shapely Dutch girlfriend. English bike has rear rack suitable for ferret or fishing kit.

hotbike 08-11-12 09:48 AM

I want to hear the term "English Racer".

A friend of mine sold an old English Racer recently... He got $150.00 for it! Probably more than the bike cost when it was new.

mprelaw 08-11-12 11:16 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by hotbike (Post 14592914)
I want to hear the term "English Racer".

A friend of mine sold an old English Racer recently... He got $150.00 for it! Probably more than the bike cost when it was new.

It was always a 10 speed Raleigh when I was a kid.

wahoonc 08-11-12 11:44 AM

I know the current crop of "Dutch" bikes, especially the nicer ones are built with galvanized and stainless components as well as being powder coated. The older Raleighs had excellent nickel/chrome plating that always seems to clean up. I think the Raleighs tend to be a bit lighter than their Dutch counterparts. I have owned plenty of Raleighs but have never owned a true Dutch bike, unless you count the Columbia I have that was built by Magneet, but it is a compact.

Aaron :)

conradpdx 08-12-12 11:51 AM

As Sheldon Brown states:

In some parts of the U.S. this type of bicycle was known among people who didn't know any better as an "English Racer", although they are a far cry from a racing design. Please don't call these bikes "English Racers!" while they are very nice bicycles, they have no connection whatever with racing; it is foolish and ignorant to refer to them this way

chasm54 08-12-12 12:52 PM

For info. everything you could possibly want to know about English 3-speeds.

no1mad 08-12-12 01:03 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by chasm54 (Post 14596305)
For info. everything you could possibly want to know about English 3-speeds.

Ah, I knew about the one in the Utility forum, but don't think I've ever stuck my head into C&V before. But 115 pages (and growing)? That's gonna take some time...

Sixty Fiver 08-12-12 01:07 PM

The quintessential Dutch and English roadsters are nearly identical and in many cases one will find Sturmey Archer hubs on Dutch bicycles just as you do on Raleigh and other Englsh built three speeds as their quality and reliability made them a popular choice with manufacturers all over the world.

My 1948 Rudge curbed out at 38 pounds but had no generator or light which is usually a standard feature on Dutch bicycles which tend to be heavier because of these mandatory fittings and often curb out at 45-50 pounds.

One must remember that Holland is flat as a pancake.

The Raleigh Sports has slightly steeper frame angles and is made from high tensile steel, with no generator lighting or racks they weigh 36 - 38 pounds while the Superbe weighs 42 pounds with a generator and light and stock racks.

Dutch roadsters continue to be built in the same manner they have been for 100 years and ride on 622/700c wheels while those vintage English roadsters ran on 635 / oversize wheels... Canadian built CCM roadsters also ran on 622/700c wheels.

Sixty Fiver 08-12-12 01:09 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by no1mad (Post 14596329)
Ah, I knew about the one in the Utility forum, but don't think I've ever stuck my head into C&V before. But 115 pages (and growing)? That's gonna take some time...

I am quite impressed at the amount of historical and technical information that has been added to this thread.

wahoonc 08-12-12 01:48 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by no1mad (Post 14596329)
Ah, I knew about the one in the Utility forum, but don't think I've ever stuck my head into C&V before. But 115 pages (and growing)? That's gonna take some time...

Just for the record...137 pages :D it was started on 2/22/10 and it still going strong. It does encompass just about everything and anything about the English 3 speeds. There are probably 3 sub groups that fall under the English Three speed moniker: Roadsters, Sports and Clubmen. Roadsters are probably the closest to the old Dutch bikes in terms of size, Sports are the middle weights and the Clubmen were the lightweights. They all used IGH for the most part.

Aaron :)

Condorita 08-12-12 03:09 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by conradpdx (Post 14591832)
"Dutch" is a more relaxed riding position with a lower seat position and the handle bars set higher. English 3 speed has a slightly more aggressive position higher seat position, low hand position. Yes we aren't talking much, but it's a difference.

A Dutch

http://www.linusbike.com/wp-content/...eam_detail.jpg

An English

http://www.linusbike.com/wp-content/...ssic_black.jpg

I should note that both bikes pictured above are made by Linus.

Dutch also usually comes with all accessories fenders, bell, lights. chain guard, skirt guard...etc. English 3 speeds were mostly just bike and fenders and chain guard. Of course there were exceptions (like the Superbe). But on the whole this would apply.



Of course the obvious answer is the English bike were made in England, and the Dutch bike made in Dutchlandia.

You can't fool me! English bikes are made in Britain!!

conradpdx 08-13-12 02:37 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by no1mad (Post 14596329)
Ah, I knew about the one in the Utility forum, but don't think I've ever stuck my head into C&V before. But 115 pages (and growing)? That's gonna take some time...


Took me about 3 or 4 days when I first got my Superbe. I highly recommend taking some notes, or bookmarking each page that some of the info you know you'll go back too. I'm glad i did, especially on the tool lists and AW hub fixes/tweeks. I don't think there's a part that isn't discussed in detail there.

howeeee 08-13-12 03:03 PM

One being built in England the other being built in the Netherlands (-:


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 07:05 PM.