Hi i'm new to cycling i've been riding around on a GT Hybrid 4.0 for a while now and i want to get a road bike i just cant pick which one so far i like.

Specialized Tarmac SL4 2014
and
Giant Defy 1 2014

A slight price difference i think 200.

Also think the specialized is carbon frame i've not tried them both out yet as i don't think they are stocked in my area so just looking on people's opinions.

Thanks