Bike Forums

Bike Forums (http://www.bikeforums.net/forum.php)
-   Hybrid Bicycles (http://www.bikeforums.net/hybrid-bicycles/)
-   -   First Post: Hybrid or Mountain Bike...? (http://www.bikeforums.net/hybrid-bicycles/928262-first-post-hybrid-mountain-bike.html)

ACyclingFreak 01-02-14 05:12 AM

First Post: Please advice Hybrid or Mountain Bike...?
 
Greetings all…

With the New Year commencing. I wish to fulfil my long standing wish to begin cycling, so here I am to seek your inputs.

Key points:
  • Need – To exercise and lose weight
  • Terrain of usage: City Roads (No off-roading as such)
  • Height: 5’7
  • Weight: 92kgs
  • Budget: 12K max
  • Type: Geared


Could you please suggest:
  • Should I go for a Hybrid or a MT bike to best suit my requirements?
  • What are my options within the specified budget?
  • What size would best fit me?
  • Any other key pointers…?


Look forward to a positive response.

Thanking in advance!

PS: A very Happy and Prosperous 2014 to all…

Cheers!

Bill Kapaun 01-02-14 08:29 AM

Probably hybrid.
However- Don't drop a huge amount of money on your 1st bike.
Use it to decide what you REALLY want.

loimpact 01-02-14 08:31 AM

Hybrid, for sure. The shocks and other suspension-related components on a mtn bike rob your power by absorbing what you're trying to push to the rear wheel with up/down motion. Thus no need whatsoever if you're never going to see anything but road.

In fact, some will even suggest you should just go full road bike but I am similarly very rarely on dirt/trail and I just like the way a hybrid sits & love a flat bar w/ ergo grips. Just a joy to ride.

That said, ride many bikes and find one that suits you. Be aware that not everybody's frame sizing is the same. Example: Giant's XL is a 23" frame (huge) while most folks is a 21" frame. You'll probably be in a "Medium" sized frame but the same applies. When shopping, make sure the size fits you right. One medium could be 17" frame while another could be 19' so just be aware cuz it does make a difference.

Lastly......Did you mean $12K U.S. dollars?? If so, you're giong to have a heck of a lot of fun shopping for bikes & will probably end up with 2 or more. :p If you meant, $1,200 than you'll still have plenty of fun. Recommended brands/models.....

Cannondale Quick series (my bias) ;)
Specialized Sirrus series (my 2nd choice)
Trek 7.4, 7.5, 7.6 FX series (highly regarded here)
Giant Escape series (Giant makes more frames than anyone)
GT Tachyon series
Fuji Absolute series
Diamondback Insight series

and other brands somewhat less common depending on where you live. But, ideally, just avoid anything with shocks on it if you really are mostly road riding.

Having just gone thru the process, I'm just regurgitating what I learned over the last couple months! Take your time & wait til you find the bike that fits you best. Remember....FIT is most important!

ACyclingFreak 01-02-14 08:36 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Bill Kapaun (Post 16375229)
Probably hybrid.
However- Don't drop a huge amount of money on your 1st bike.
Use it to decide what you REALLY want.

Thanks a ton! Really value your inputs, and will keep that in mind:-)

ACyclingFreak 01-02-14 08:39 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by loimpact (Post 16375232)
Hybrid, for sure.

Lastly......Did you mean $12K U.S. dollars?? If so, you're giong to have a heck of a lot of fun shopping for bikes & will probably end up with 2 or more. :p If you meant, $1,200 than you'll still have plenty of fun. Recommended brands/models.....

Having just gone thru the process, I'm just regurgitating what I learned over the last couple months! Take your time & wait til you find the bike that fits you best. Remember....FIT is most important!


Thanks for this fabulous insight and taking out your precious time to help me.

My apologies, I should have been more clear. I am in India and so the budget is mere Rs. 12000/-. The one I like is ACT 110. Here's the link:

http://www.bsahercules.com/product-features.asp?pid=200

Could you possibly advise on this or any other in this price range...

Thanks a billion:)

oddjob2 01-02-14 08:49 AM

I'd look for a used bike. Then if you don't stick with it, you won't have a major investment. Excellent rigid chromoly steel mountain bikes from the 1990's can be had for less than $200. A set of smooth road tires on them for $40 make them ride as well as any hybrid. You would need a 15"-16" frame.

There are many lightly used hybrids available too, but you'll likely spend more for them.

My personal brand preferences are Trek, Gary Fisher, or Specialized.

oddjob2 01-02-14 08:55 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ACyclingFreak (Post 16375259)
Thanks for this fabulous insight and taking out your precious time to help me.

My apologies, I should have been more clear. I am in India and so the budget is mere Rs. 12000/-. The one I like is ACT 110. Here's the link:

http://www.bsahercules.com/product-features.asp?pid=200

Could you possibly advise on this or any other in this price range...

Thanks a billion:)

Aluminum frame, low quality component group.

Wanderer 01-02-14 04:49 PM

I really don't see anything wrong with your listed choice.

SlipKid65 01-02-14 05:20 PM

While you're shopping, be sure to check out some road bikes too.

I bought a hybrid (Giant Escape) a year and a half ago, and it is a great bike. I put 2000 miles on it, and decided to test ride some road bikes. I ended up buying an "endurance" road bike (Felt Z5) and have been putting a ton of miles on it.

I thought that the more upright position of the hybrid would be the most comfortable for me, but I find the road bike much more comfortable to ride, especially longer distances, than the hybrid.

The hybrid has become my "pickup truck" for trips to the store or if I'm gonna be on less than perfect pavement.

ACyclingFreak 01-02-14 10:26 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by SlipKid65 (Post 16376955)
While you're shopping, be sure to check out some road bikes too.

Thanks for the details. But here some of the road bikes are not available in the sense that the choices are limited, and the budget to as it will be my first bike I really don't intend to spend too much.

I did look at some of the road bikes but couldn't underline one except for the one I posted a link for, which is a hybrid.


Thanks for the insights.

fietsbob 01-03-14 02:03 AM

Know little about the bikes in India.. that was the seller's location in link.

In general the assembly worker's attention to detail

is a lot of what the good or less, is, in the final bike sold ..

and that is Unknown .... Is this from a shop specializing in Bicycles?

the exchange rate in Rupees to dollar is also unknown ..

ACyclingFreak 01-03-14 02:30 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by fietsbob (Post 16378042)
Know little about the bikes in India.. that was the seller's location in link.

In general the assembly worker's attention to detail

is a lot of what the good or less, is, in the final bike sold ..

and that is Unknown .... Is this from a shop specializing in Bicycles?

the exchange rate in Rupees to dollar is also unknown ..

The link was from a manufacturers site.

I understand it is very difficult to comment without actually testing it out. It is from a shop which is primarily selling cycles of all types. The exchange rate at the moment is around Rs. 60 odd I guess...

Thanks a lot!

ACyclingFreak 01-03-14 06:42 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Wanderer (Post 16376863)
I really don't see anything wrong with your listed choice.

Thanks for the confirmation. I'm in the process of finalizing this or any other. I'll surely post some pics too. You guys are awesome!!!

ACyclingFreak 01-07-14 04:35 AM

Hi Friends and Experts,

So the time has come when I finalise my purchase.

But need your last bit of comments and expert advise. Here are the options that I've managed to short list:

FireFox Cyclone
Hercules ACT 110
RockRider 5.0

May I request for your final go ahead on the one I should buy.

Please please advise!

Thanks a lot!

Pics will follow soon i.e once I have finalised it.

treadtread 01-07-14 01:48 PM

I've seen some India specific bike forums (I was looking because I was really curious to see what we get in India). Try asking there. Which part of India are you in? When I last visited Pune, I went to some bike shops (forget the area - somewhere near the railway station I think). I saw Cannondales there, about 25-30k - much higher than your budget. I believe there are bike shops in Bangalore though, where you will get cheaper, but still good, bikes. Try asking here: http://www.bikeszone.com/forum/

For the models you listed - can you link them please?

02Giant 01-07-14 08:40 PM

http://www.cyclists.in/photo/24cyclone-1
http://www.bsahercules.com/product-features.asp?pid=200
http://www.decathlon.co.uk/rockrider...d_8202062.html

ACyclingFreak 01-07-14 11:47 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by treadtread (Post 16390880)
I've seen some India specific bike forums (I was looking because I was really curious to see what we get in India). Try asking there. Which part of India are you in? When I last visited Pune, I went to some bike shops (forget the area - somewhere near the railway station I think). I saw Cannondales there, about 25-30k - much higher than your budget. I believe there are bike shops in Bangalore though, where you will get cheaper, but still good, bikes. Try asking here: http://www.bikeszone.com/forum/

For the models you listed - can you link them please?

Thanks TreadTread - I have looked through the forum. I must say was quite informative.

ACyclingFreak 01-07-14 11:47 PM

02Giant - Thanks for this wonderful help.

Ghazmh 01-13-14 11:33 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Bill Kapaun (Post 16375229)
Probably hybrid.
However- Don't drop a huge amount of money on your 1st bike.
Use it to decide what you REALLY want.


so true, my recent hybrid was a Gary Fisher Montare. I found myself riding on roads and bike paths. Enentually I realized that i should be riding a road bike and thats what I now ride the most. Start off with ahybrid. If a mountain uke is what you eventually gravitate towords than make it your second bike.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 11:19 AM.