Which Fender??? SKS or Bontrager
#1
Loving LD
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jan 2010
Location: Mumbai
Posts: 150
Bikes: Scott Speedster S50, Trek 3700, (Italian Vintage) - Olmo Steel Roadbike, Surly Cross Check-LD bike
Mentioned: 0 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 0 Post(s)
Likes: 0
Liked 0 Times
in
0 Posts
Which Fender??? SKS or Bontrager
Hi,
Been almost a year since I got my LD rig a Cross Check, at the time I got a Scott Chromoplast fender, while it serves it's purpose it's a little flimsy. The front Srut bracket had broken within a few days but I still managed with it somehow by doing a quick fix job with superglue. I installed the fender again since it's rainy season now... and the bracket has once again failed.
I'll be taking this bike to PBP so thought I'll get new fenders instead on relying on my old ones. Can't decide over which ones to get, there are a few options
1. SKS CAB mudguards
2. Bontrager NCS Road
3. SKS Wide Road
I'm a bit confused of which one to go for!!!! What I can make out is that clearly SKS stands on its own when it comes to build quality, finish and looks. While the Bontrager are new ones and seem to have the practicality with adjustable struts, so can be used on another bike if required.
So what would you guys put your money on??
Been almost a year since I got my LD rig a Cross Check, at the time I got a Scott Chromoplast fender, while it serves it's purpose it's a little flimsy. The front Srut bracket had broken within a few days but I still managed with it somehow by doing a quick fix job with superglue. I installed the fender again since it's rainy season now... and the bracket has once again failed.
I'll be taking this bike to PBP so thought I'll get new fenders instead on relying on my old ones. Can't decide over which ones to get, there are a few options
1. SKS CAB mudguards
2. Bontrager NCS Road
3. SKS Wide Road
I'm a bit confused of which one to go for!!!! What I can make out is that clearly SKS stands on its own when it comes to build quality, finish and looks. While the Bontrager are new ones and seem to have the practicality with adjustable struts, so can be used on another bike if required.
So what would you guys put your money on??
#2
Senior Member
Join Date: Dec 2008
Location: Seattle, WA
Posts: 649
Mentioned: 16 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 81 Post(s)
Liked 221 Times
in
65 Posts
I have no experience with the Bontragers so I can't comment on those.
Just to be difficult, I'm going to suggest a couple other options you didn't mention. On my commuter bike I went through about three sets of SKS fenders in three years. They all failed where the rear fender attaches to the seatstay bridge, but each in slightly different ways. Then I tried Planet Bike Cascadias and they're still going strong after three years.
For my brevet bike I like aluminum fenders. They offer better coverage, they hold up very well and they look shnazzy. I've had great luck with the Velo Orange aluminum fenders. They're a little more work to install, but once on, they're more like a permanent part of the bike than any plastic fenders.
Just to be difficult, I'm going to suggest a couple other options you didn't mention. On my commuter bike I went through about three sets of SKS fenders in three years. They all failed where the rear fender attaches to the seatstay bridge, but each in slightly different ways. Then I tried Planet Bike Cascadias and they're still going strong after three years.
For my brevet bike I like aluminum fenders. They offer better coverage, they hold up very well and they look shnazzy. I've had great luck with the Velo Orange aluminum fenders. They're a little more work to install, but once on, they're more like a permanent part of the bike than any plastic fenders.
#3
Loving LD
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jan 2010
Location: Mumbai
Posts: 150
Bikes: Scott Speedster S50, Trek 3700, (Italian Vintage) - Olmo Steel Roadbike, Surly Cross Check-LD bike
Mentioned: 0 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 0 Post(s)
Likes: 0
Liked 0 Times
in
0 Posts
well the problem is I live in India & here such quality fenders are not available & I'm not sure if the VO or Planet Bike will ship here. Evans & CRC do so the only ones available there are an option!!!!
BTW the local metal fenders here are made of Steel; so heavy that you can seriously hurt someone if you hit with them .
BTW the local metal fenders here are made of Steel; so heavy that you can seriously hurt someone if you hit with them .
#4
just another gosling
Join Date: Feb 2007
Location: Everett, WA
Posts: 19,528
Bikes: CoMo Speedster 2003, Trek 5200, CAAD 9, Fred 2004
Mentioned: 115 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 3886 Post(s)
Liked 1,938 Times
in
1,383 Posts
I have no experience with the Bontragers so I can't comment on those.
Just to be difficult, I'm going to suggest a couple other options you didn't mention. On my commuter bike I went through about three sets of SKS fenders in three years. They all failed where the rear fender attaches to the seatstay bridge, but each in slightly different ways. Then I tried Planet Bike Cascadias and they're still going strong after three years.
For my brevet bike I like aluminum fenders. They offer better coverage, they hold up very well and they look shnazzy. I've had great luck with the Velo Orange aluminum fenders. They're a little more work to install, but once on, they're more like a permanent part of the bike than any plastic fenders.
Just to be difficult, I'm going to suggest a couple other options you didn't mention. On my commuter bike I went through about three sets of SKS fenders in three years. They all failed where the rear fender attaches to the seatstay bridge, but each in slightly different ways. Then I tried Planet Bike Cascadias and they're still going strong after three years.
For my brevet bike I like aluminum fenders. They offer better coverage, they hold up very well and they look shnazzy. I've had great luck with the Velo Orange aluminum fenders. They're a little more work to install, but once on, they're more like a permanent part of the bike than any plastic fenders.
Last edited by Carbonfiberboy; 06-22-11 at 12:16 PM.