LadyX

Hi,

Ok so, I'm looking into buying a bike for the first time in forever. I've only ever had Walmart type bikes growing up, but seeing as I am moving away from home, and biking/bussing are going to be my new modes of transportation, I want something a little better. Speed is not terribly important to me at this point, and roads in my area are in pretty poor condition.

I'm torn between two right now. A Raleigh comfort hybrid, which is a look I love, and has a very nice low step thru, which I appreciate because I intend to put a cargo rack on it and I won't be able to swing my leg up and over the back once one is attached. And a Haro Flightline One ST, mostly because I like the color and my mom gets a 50% company discount on all Haro products. The shops in my area don't have the frame size I need built and on display though, so I'm not 100% sure how the smaller size would fit. But I did try the 17in frame, and I don't see why the 14in wouldn't work, just be a little higher step throug than the Raleigh.

Any info and opinions would be greatly appreciated please, and thank you!

Phildog

I'm sorry that I couldn't tell you anything specific on either bike. However, I would suggest looking at factors such as weight...since you're gonna commute with it. The only thing worse than commuting on a heavy bike is commuting on a heavier bike. Also, look at the components that are installed. Get a good feel for a quality-per-dollar comparison.

Also, check the fit of both frame sizes. It sounds like you're gonna be on your bike a LOT, so it must fit you properly.

Sorry I couldn't tell you more of exactly of what you seek, but I hope it helps you make a wise decision.

Good luck!

jwarner

I'm afraid I don't know either of these models specifically. I can tell you that I've greatly enjoyed my Raleigh Sojourn (other than the paint which is easily scratched), and looking at the current build list for their 2015 bikes, they only seem to be getting better.

closdubois

50% discount on Haro???? um, buy that bike for sure. And then get some nicer Haro upgrades on it. and then let me get in on that discount as well.

And there is a huge difference between a 17 and 14in frame.

osco53

Hero,, never heard of em'

Raleigh was an old company when I was young, about,,,13 centuries ago.

Just sayin..

Zephyr11

Never heard of Hero either.

Now Haro, on the other hand...in the 80s, those were THE BMX bikes to have!

To the OP, you're comparing a step-through hybrid to a mountain bike. What kind of riding are you actually doing and what kind of bike are you looking for? I know you're saying commuting on bad roads, but that could mean anything from uneven roads to "screw the road, I'm taking the shortcut down these stairs," and no one knows how far these commutes are either.

LadyX

Uneven roads and cut through grass, no jumping stairs or anything. 8 mile each way trips, max, average I would say two mile each way trips. I've really got no idea what I need or would be best, or would be sufficient.

osco53

LadyX,, take a look around and see what other people are riding where You will ride.
Go back to that Local bike shop and talk to them... FIT IS EVERYTHING ! TEST RIDE TEST RIDE !
If they don't tirelessly work with you to help you, find another bike shop.

An Internal 3 speed hub may be all you need, or a five speed, maybe more, depending on you, your physical condition.
Do you need to climb hills ? Like San francisco ?? More gears and a lighter bike will make a big diff there.


Mountain bikes can be complex and even entry level with the front Sun Tour fork may be overkill.

https://citybikes.com/product/giant-v...s-193993-1.htm

https://www.raleighusa.com/bikes-wome...e-urban-spirit

Those above would, 'Cut through the grass' just fine and after you got good at dodging pot holes you'd prolly
get a speeding ticket

If you can pass on the step thru you will be able to get a lighter leaner faster bike, faster as in easier to pedal..

bananafruitcake

+1 on make sure it fits
and consider going the hybrid route vs mtb...

worth considering (a TEST ride) and this time of year potential super savings
Nishiki Women's Montour Hybrid Bike 2014 | DICK'S Sporting Goods

LadyX

... I actually think that's the Raleigh I was looking at in the shop. Lol.

wvridgerider

Fit, Fit, Fit. Test ride the bikes you are interested in and let the shop know what you think. If something doesnt feel correct ask questions. Not sure where you live but if you ride year round in in the rain and in bad conditions fenders are a must. They make a big difference. You will also wear out drivetrains quicker if they salt the roads. Just go to as many shops as you can and see what they have to offer. Good luck.