Bike Forums

Bike Forums (https://www.bikeforums.net/forum.php)
-   Professional Cycling For the Fans (https://www.bikeforums.net/professional-cycling-fans/)
-   -   Can an African Win the Tour de France? (https://www.bikeforums.net/professional-cycling-fans/866984-can-african-win-tour-de-france.html)

EntenteCordiale 01-11-13 02:44 PM

Can an African Win the Tour de France?
 
An interesting feature on the prospects for African cycling from the BBC:

http://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/0/cycling/20842499

cplager 01-11-13 03:41 PM


Originally Posted by EntenteCordiale (Post 15146268)
An interesting feature on the prospects for African cycling from the BBC:

http://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/0/cycling/20842499

I'm sure it's more a question of when instead of if.

hamster 01-11-13 04:08 PM

The key is that substantial numbers of local kids must have the conditions to train and to compete while still in school. Centers as described in the article are good for the next step, but first you need to be good at identifying talented individuals.

The problem with Africa is not only that most Africans simply can't afford decent bikes, but it is said that the median African lives about 7 miles from the nearest paved road. That's why there are lots of renowned African runners but almost no cyclists.

We should sooner see a winner from South America, at least they already have the infrastructure. There have already been a few strong showings by Colombians in recent history.

Cat4Lifer 01-11-13 04:35 PM

Pretty good chance this year, with Froome.

johnny99 01-11-13 04:59 PM


Originally Posted by Cat4Lifer (Post 15146716)
Pretty good chance this year, with Froome.

Froome should have won last year. Born and raised in Africa.

hamster 01-11-13 05:05 PM

Froome is as "African" as Obama is "Black". Yes. technically both of them are, but that's not what we normally mean by those words: Froome is not ethnic African (he's almost pure British, not a drop of African blood there) and Obama is not a descendant of African-American slaves.

EntenteCordiale 01-11-13 05:11 PM

This year's Haute Route featured a team of Kenyans with an interesting story and an unorthodox entry into the world of cycling:

We have a multi-tribal team. Most come from rural areas and none of them completed secondary school. These are hard men... they have dug 10 meter boreholes with their hands and simple tools, hauled 90kg sacks of corn up hills, endured abandonment and deaths in their families, and generally experienced deprivation throughout their lives.” Almost all of them use a bicycle, the basic 1-geared Black Mamba, in some capacity in their daily lives.

More about the Kenyan Riders here.

Cycling is an incredibly popular mode of transportation in East Africa particularly, and as their infrastructure develops it's only a matter of time before their teams become competitive. The recent Tour of Rwanda showed off a lot of pristine road surfaces and Team Rwanda have to turn away countless numbers of ambitious bicycle taxi drivers who ride out to their base in the mountains at Musanze in the hope of getting noticed by the team. the sport seems to be really big in Kenya, Ethiopia and Eritrea (the Italian influence?) too.

The South Africans are the continental leaders in terms of professionalism though (unsurprising given the relative wealth of the country). Their MTN Qhubeka team has a 70% African roster (mostly South Africans but also Eritreans, Ethiopians, Rwandans and Algerians) and is targeting participation in a Grand Tour by 2014.

EntenteCordiale 01-11-13 05:18 PM


Originally Posted by hamster (Post 15146808)
Froome is as "African" as Obama is "Black". Yes. technically both of them are, but that's not what we normally mean by those words: Froome is not ethnic African (he's almost pure British, not a drop of African blood there) and Obama is not a descendant of African-American slaves.

Perhaps it's fair to say that Kenya can claim Chris Froome as one of their own (he did feel Kenyan enough to represent them at the UCI World Road Championships), but Kenyan cycling cannot do the same. After all, he was trained as a road cyclist primarily in South Africa and the UK, and had this to say about the time he spent representing Kenya:

"Although I was riding under the Kenyan flag I made it clear that I had always carried a British passport and felt British."

Cat4Lifer 01-11-13 08:38 PM

African blood?
Why don't people say what they mean?
If one means to ask: will a black ever win the TDF, then ask: will a black ever win the TDF. lol

EntenteCordiale 01-12-13 05:03 AM

But if a black European (of which there are a great many) won a Grand Tour, I wouldn't consider that a victory for Africa. It's more a question of someone who is culturally African and is a product of African cycling.

ultraman6970 01-12-13 05:15 AM

Well if i had the chance of a rhino or a cheetah after my butt in the middle of road i would get fast and strong quite fast!!

As for winning? well... there was a thread about colors, races and cycling performance moving around, the guys in the picture look pretty european mixed to me, no matter where they are from tho. Would be cool to see them in the TdF.

Cat4Lifer 01-12-13 12:15 PM


Originally Posted by EntenteCordiale (Post 15148223)
But if a black European (of which there are a great many) won a Grand Tour, I wouldn't consider that a victory for Africa. It's more a question of someone who is culturally African and is a product of African cycling.

So you see a Black African GT victory as a "victory" for Africa.
Well, if you mean Black Africans from West Sub-Saharan Africa -- if I were you, I wouldn't hold my breath.
Now, a Black from Kenya, maybe one day.

EntenteCordiale 01-12-13 07:20 PM


Originally Posted by Cat4Lifer (Post 15149181)
So you see a Black African GT victory as a "victory" for Africa.
Well, if you mean Black Africans from West Sub-Saharan Africa -- if I were you, I wouldn't hold my breath.
Now, a Black from Kenya, maybe one day.

That's not what I meant. I was replying to your comment:

African blood?
Why don't people say what they mean?
If one means to ask: will a black ever win the TDF, then ask: will a black ever win the TDF. lol

The point I was trying to make is that colour is irrelevant. I don't consider Froome to be an African cyclist, not because he is white, but because he is culturally British. A champion from North Africa or a white South African would have complete legitimacy as an African champion.

merlinextraligh 01-14-13 09:21 AM


Originally Posted by ultraman6970 (Post 15148234)
Well if i had the chance of a rhino or a cheetah after my butt in the middle of road i would get fast and strong quite fast!!

.

It's the antelope you have to watch for.


Cat4Lifer 01-14-13 10:59 AM


Originally Posted by EntenteCordiale (Post 15150393)

The point I was trying to make is that colour is irrelevant. I don't consider Froome to be an African cyclist, not because he is white, but because he is culturally British.

I'd imagine someone from Kenya is as culturally different from someone from Morocco as someone
from the United States. Seems more than a bit silly to speak of or intimate there is such a thing as
"African culture," when the cultures among the peoples of Africa are so different.

baj32161 01-14-13 12:43 PM

Yes :D

Racer Ex 01-14-13 03:44 PM


Originally Posted by Cat4Lifer (Post 15155544)
Seems more than a bit silly to speak of or intimate there is such a thing as
"African culture," when the cultures among the peoples of Africa are so different.

But they all look alike*.

You know, it'll be nice when we stop making any kind of a "deal" about when/if can/can't some one do something based on whatever stupid criteria we use to break people up into little granfalloons

Hell of a lot more difference between a Great Dane and a chihuahua then there are among people. Still dogs. Still people.

* This is sarcasm.

Garfield Cat 01-19-13 07:43 AM


Originally Posted by Cat4Lifer (Post 15155544)
I'd imagine someone from Kenya is as culturally different from someone from Morocco as someone
from the United States. Seems more than a bit silly to speak of or intimate there is such a thing as
"African culture," when the cultures among the peoples of Africa are so different.

anyone from a poor background will have the "hunger" to achieve, to survive, to excel or to be dragged down by the plight of poverty and ignorance. "the World is a Ghetto".

work4bike 01-19-13 09:07 AM

Kind of a moot point, we're all Africans. My great, great, great...grand daddy was a Black African and so was yours ;) http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=p4AwIkzut48

The genetic difference that changes our skin color is so insignificant that, genetically speaking, there is no such thing as race.

Garfield Cat 01-19-13 09:35 AM


Originally Posted by john gault (Post 15174018)
Kind of a moot point, we're all Africans. My great, great, great...grand daddy was a Black African and so was yours ;) http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=p4AwIkzut48

The genetic difference that changes our skin color is so insignificant that, genetically speaking, there is no such thing as race.

Maybe more accurate to say that we are all **** Sapiens. The "All African" thing is the new card that is getting a lot of play these days.

Cat4Lifer 01-19-13 12:37 PM


Originally Posted by john gault (Post 15174018)
The genetic difference that changes our skin color is so insignificant that, genetically speaking, there is no such thing as race.

except that there are genetic differences among "human populations" or "human races."

eja_ bottecchia 01-19-13 12:44 PM


Originally Posted by Cat4Lifer (Post 15146716)
Pretty good chance this year, with Froome.

Yep.

oldbobcat 01-19-13 05:57 PM


Originally Posted by cplager (Post 15146488)
I'm sure it's more a question of when instead of if.

The February issue of Cycle Sport has been covering the Tour of Rwanda for two seasons now. After several months of mire in the Armstrong doping scandal, it was truly heartwarming to learn how the sport is growing from the grassroots in new parts of the world.

Any part of the world that has good racing will eventually produce champions of international caliber.

hueyhoolihan 01-19-13 06:56 PM


Originally Posted by Cat4Lifer (Post 15146716)
Pretty good chance this year, with Froome.

i took this as proof that brevity is the soul of wit...

jon c. 01-19-13 07:15 PM

The "All African" thing is the new card that is getting a lot of play these days.

Seems to me that's been the prevailing theory for the last 50 years or more.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 11:21 PM.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.