Bike Forums

Bike Forums (http://www.bikeforums.net/forum.php)
-   Recumbent (http://www.bikeforums.net/recumbent/)
-   -   Why are some recumbent so slow? (http://www.bikeforums.net/recumbent/922706-why-some-recumbent-so-slow.html)

Creakyknees 11-18-13 09:53 AM

Why are some recumbent so slow?
 
I saw quite a few people on their recumbent in Dallas' White Rock Lake Park on weekends. The recumbent are so slow that they almost weren't moving (I saw the leaves passed by them from underneath being swiped). Once when I came up from behind one of them, I thought it was stopped and was worried I nearly ran it over . Isn't it not only unpleasant to be slower than anything around you, but also dangerous if there is a bike, car, big truck, etc., on the road? They could also be run over by another bike and quite easily invisible to a vehicle driver until too late. Those people were almost lying on the ground.

markus_mudd 11-18-13 12:22 PM

They're just slower cyclists and it won't matter what kind of bike they choose.

What sticks out to me is that this quote from your post is nearly identical to statements from motorists against ALL cyclists. ---> "Once when I came up from behind one of them, I thought it was stopped and was worried I nearly ran it over . Isn't it not only unpleasant to be slower than anything around you, but also dangerous if there is a bike, car, big truck, etc., on the road?"

Give the recumbents a break and let them smell the roses....Or stop and talk to them about it. As with all human powered vehicles, it's still the engine that determines the speed of the ride.

jimbalaya 11-18-13 01:51 PM

You could say this about any type of bicycle. What's the point of posting this here? This topic would be better off in the trolling forum.

BlazingPedals 11-19-13 06:43 AM

I ask that same question all the time on big rides: "Why are all the upright bikes so slow?" Maybe I should post my question on the road bike forum and be surprised if a few of them get riled up. Or did you do that already?

lovemachine 11-19-13 07:46 AM

Sorry, I fed the trolls this time!

My usual response is silence, but cabin fever may be setting in. I thought it was funny myself but I don't want my crude humor to reflect poorly on this entire group who is probably already viewed as strange by the "normal people"

Dudelsack 11-19-13 10:16 AM

wut

Retro Grouch 11-19-13 11:32 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by markus_mudd (Post 16256466)
They're just slower cyclists and it won't matter what kind of bike they choose.

Quote:

Originally Posted by jimbalaya (Post 16256725)
You could say this about any type of bicycle. What's the point of posting this here? This topic would be better off in the trolling forum.

Yeah, it's really a dumb question. Tells us what kind of person the questioner is.

dekindy 11-19-13 12:41 PM

If you know they are trolls, then don't feed them! I find some of the replies are ruder than the probable troll.

rydabent 11-21-13 09:45 AM

The OP apparently seems surprised that all of a sudden "here is this recumbent in front of him". Maybe if he was on a bent and not staring down at his front wheel, he might not have been so "surprised". Some of us ride at different speeds on different days. Some of us never ride at a speed that produces heart rate that is at 95.983729654% of our maximum heart rate. :)

merlinextraligh 11-21-13 10:17 AM

and wuts up with the white beards?

dcrowell 11-21-13 12:26 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by merlinextraligh (Post 16265664)
and wuts up with the white beards?

I can't even grow a beard. :(
I have the aero-belly though. :)

delcrossv 11-21-13 03:34 PM

This is a good thread for this vid. :D


rydabent 11-22-13 09:55 AM

del

Love that video!!!!

StickBiker 11-22-13 03:50 PM

Maybe CreakyKnees would care to race a recumbent rider? Would he look like he is standing still in my rear view mirror?

cycle_maven 11-22-13 04:55 PM

I tried to draft a recumbent one time on a diamond-frame road bike. Very unsatisfying experience. Plus the flag kept flapping in my face.

noglider 11-22-13 05:14 PM

If you were a very slow rider, you might find it uncomfortable to ride an upright bike. A recumbent would be a good choice.

;)

Dudelsack 11-22-13 07:56 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by dekindy (Post 16259766)
If you know they are trolls, then don't feed them! I find some of the replies are ruder than the probable troll.

Probable?

JanMM 11-23-13 09:02 AM

A hit-and-run troll.

Dudelsack 11-23-13 09:36 AM

Anyway, ignoring the troll motives of the OP: I'm a slow bent rider. When I rode DFs, I was slow on those too.

I'm slow. Always have been. Always will be.

Put me on a Harley and I'd figure out a way to keep my average moving speeds at 12 MPH.

I would take pride in randonneuring and touring. I just renewed my RUSA number for two years.

I'll never shell out the hapless masses on a group ride. I'm totally cool with that.

BTW, the flag in the face comment was pretty funny.

BlazingPedals 11-23-13 01:00 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by StickBiker (Post 16269847)
Maybe CreakyKnees would care to race a recumbent rider? Would he look like he is standing still in my rear view mirror?

I dislike challenges, even in this case. The reason being, it's still impossible to separate the engine from the vehicle. There will always be a difference in experience and wattage, making the results of questionable value. If CN really believes that bents are slow, it's only because he's never seen a fast one. Sooner or later, he probably will.

rydabent 11-25-13 09:08 AM

When the posted video is over wait till several other windows for viewing appear. Click on the one that says recumbents cant climb. Its great too!

merlinextraligh 11-25-13 09:19 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by BlazingPedals (Post 16271898)
I dislike challenges, even in this case. The reason being, it's still impossible to separate the engine from the vehicle. There will always be a difference in experience and wattage, making the results of questionable value. If CN really believes that bents are slow, it's only because he's never seen a fast one. Sooner or later, he probably will.

And that's the bottom line.

No doubt, low rider recumbants have an aerodynamic advantage, and a strong rider on a bent designed for speed can be very fast.

What I think strikes non bent riders however, is how many bent riders there are that will spend a lot of time telling you how fast their bikes are, but tehn ride them very slowly.

It may just be that "that guy" stick outs and leaves the most memorable impression.

JanMM 11-25-13 12:09 PM

Can't really tell from the OP whether he's talking about recumbent bicycles or tricycles. (Or, both) To overgeneralize, both low racers (bikes) and tadpoles (trikes) are very low but low racers are ridden significantly faster than tadpoles.

fietsbob 11-25-13 06:16 PM

Slow? Answer: Velomobile ! aerodynamics, FTW.

Fastest bikes are recumbents , low racers in a streamlined body.

Murray Missile 11-25-13 08:34 PM

The first time I ever saw a recumbent was about 1982 and I was on my Miyata 510. I tried to chase the guy down to ask him about it and could never even get close. I was about 27 and the recumbent pilot looked to be in his early 60's. I finally admitted defeat, put my tail between my seat stays and headed for home.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 09:23 PM.