Carbon wheel quality?
#1
Senior Member
Thread Starter
Carbon wheel quality?
I have a pair of Reynolds AR80 carbon wheels on my 2015 Shiv (rim brake, clincher). I like them quite a bit, however, I do notice the front 80mm deep wheel will get pushed around a bit in windy conditions. I'd like to find just a single front wheel to run on windier days so I'm looking around. The problem seems to be that it's a little more difficult to find just a single wheel. Also, because I prefer to run both 80s most of the time, I'd rather not put out a bunch of cash for a wheel that's only going to see use ~25% of the time.
I know names like Zipp, Enve, Reynolds and Mavic, but even if I can find just a single front wheel in a 30-40mm profile, I'm still looking at $400-$500 or more. Which leads me to conclude I'm going to have to look at cheaper wheel options from Asia. I personally don't have any problems with products produced over there, but I avoid Chinese as much as possible (for multiple reasons it would be best to leave unexplored).
Of course, I don't really know what manufacturers to avoid and which ones make a quality wheel and provide good service. This is where I turn to the good people of BF. I could spend hours on my internets doing various searches and reading all kinds of reviews. But I kind of figure this forum is something of a clearing house for exactly the information I'm looking for. I get that a lot of it will be personal preference, and there will be some conflicting opinions, but I expect I will trust many of your personal experiences over some random review I just pulled up in a search.
So who do you like? Who should I avoid?
I know names like Zipp, Enve, Reynolds and Mavic, but even if I can find just a single front wheel in a 30-40mm profile, I'm still looking at $400-$500 or more. Which leads me to conclude I'm going to have to look at cheaper wheel options from Asia. I personally don't have any problems with products produced over there, but I avoid Chinese as much as possible (for multiple reasons it would be best to leave unexplored).
Of course, I don't really know what manufacturers to avoid and which ones make a quality wheel and provide good service. This is where I turn to the good people of BF. I could spend hours on my internets doing various searches and reading all kinds of reviews. But I kind of figure this forum is something of a clearing house for exactly the information I'm looking for. I get that a lot of it will be personal preference, and there will be some conflicting opinions, but I expect I will trust many of your personal experiences over some random review I just pulled up in a search.
So who do you like? Who should I avoid?
#2
I'm good to go!
Join Date: Jul 2017
Location: Mississippi
Posts: 14,703
Bikes: Tarmac Disc Comp Di2 - 2020
Mentioned: 50 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 6063 Post(s)
Liked 4,694 Times
in
3,238 Posts
If it's the wind pushing the front wheel on windy days that is your issue, then that is going to be due to the higher profile or deeper section rim more than any other thing I would think. So if that is the issue you wish to solve, you'll just need to get a single front wheel with less section height to run for windy days where gusts might bother you otherwise.
You'll get use to the aesthetic difference of the rear having a deeper section than the front after you look at it often enough. And if it's a different design model altogether, that might take a while longer to get use too.
You'll get use to the aesthetic difference of the rear having a deeper section than the front after you look at it often enough. And if it's a different design model altogether, that might take a while longer to get use too.
#3
Senior Member
Thread Starter
If it's the wind pushing the front wheel on windy days that is your issue, then that is going to be due to the higher profile or deeper section rim more than any other thing I would think. So if that is the issue you wish to solve, you'll just need to get a single front wheel with less section height to run for windy days where gusts might bother you otherwise.
You'll get use to the aesthetic difference of the rear having a deeper section than the front after you look at it often enough.
You'll get use to the aesthetic difference of the rear having a deeper section than the front after you look at it often enough.
#4
I'm good to go!
Join Date: Jul 2017
Location: Mississippi
Posts: 14,703
Bikes: Tarmac Disc Comp Di2 - 2020
Mentioned: 50 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 6063 Post(s)
Liked 4,694 Times
in
3,238 Posts
If you haven't run the more deeper section wheels long enough to get use to the needed input from your arms often enough, then it might just be you need to bear with it for a while longer.
And if it's not a every day thing, probably few people will make snarky comments about the wheel mismatch between front and back if even if you use the alloy front with less section.
And if it's not a every day thing, probably few people will make snarky comments about the wheel mismatch between front and back if even if you use the alloy front with less section.
#5
Senior Member
Thread Starter
I really don't want to go with an alloy on the front for several reason. For one, that means it would necessitate a brake pad change and caliper adjustment any time I switch. Really not a huge inconvenience, but still an inconvenience. Also, I already have alloy spare wheels, so hard to justify an additional purchase. But none of them are tubeless. So then my dilemma would be to run a narrow tube wheel on the front and a wide tubeless carbon wheel on the back, swap pads and adjust calipers any time I need to change from one to the other, or buy a compromise wheel that only works with that bike that may have some of the features I want, or just find one front wheel with a shallower section that's a simple swap in and out. I would prefer the latter.
#6
climber has-been
Join Date: Dec 2004
Location: Palo Alto, CA
Posts: 6,956
Bikes: Scott Addict R1, Felt Z1
Mentioned: 10 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 3297 Post(s)
Liked 3,386 Times
in
1,713 Posts
I'm really liking my new wheelset from Winspace. Yes, they are made in China, but they have a very good reputation.
I assume you're looking for rim brake, so these might fit the bill, and they're not that expensive:
Winspace: Lún Routte 45mm Rim Brake Wheelset
You might end up liking them better than your current wheels.
I assume you're looking for rim brake, so these might fit the bill, and they're not that expensive:
Winspace: Lún Routte 45mm Rim Brake Wheelset
You might end up liking them better than your current wheels.
__________________
Ride, Rest, Repeat. ROUVY: terrymorse
Ride, Rest, Repeat. ROUVY: terrymorse
#7
Senior Member
Thread Starter
So another option I'm considering is just buying a used bike that already has some decent carbon wheels, swapping them out for a spare set of alloy wheels that came with my Shiv, and then selling the bike.
Here's a decent example
https://lasvegas.craigslist.org/bik/...726659106.html
Not saying this exact one (I would be too tempted to keep it) but maybe talk the seller down to $1k, swap out those wheels and then put it back on CL for $500-600. Somebody gets a solid bike for a good price and I get the wheels I want.
Tempting.
Here's a decent example
https://lasvegas.craigslist.org/bik/...726659106.html
Not saying this exact one (I would be too tempted to keep it) but maybe talk the seller down to $1k, swap out those wheels and then put it back on CL for $500-600. Somebody gets a solid bike for a good price and I get the wheels I want.
Tempting.
#8
Senior Member
Join Date: Oct 2013
Location: Mich
Posts: 7,268
Bikes: RSO E-tire dropper fixie brifter
Mentioned: 0 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 6 Post(s)
Liked 2,902 Times
in
1,879 Posts
idk how much you care about the finished look, but if you are, try to find accurate photos of the one/set you're eyeing up. Some look more grey, others have a higher gloss, then you have those with massive decals that cannot be peeled off.
I understand that a budget is of concern, but if for some reason you do end up having to spend the loot... maybe you could find a source that'll offer to sell a pair of fronts if you dont have any need for a rear wheel built.
I understand that a budget is of concern, but if for some reason you do end up having to spend the loot... maybe you could find a source that'll offer to sell a pair of fronts if you dont have any need for a rear wheel built.
__________________
-Oh Hey!
-Oh Hey!
#9
Senior Member
In case you didn't know, Reynolds wheels are made in Hangzhou (two hours drive west of Shanghai).
So you don't want to pay the cost of Western brands, and you also don't want to buy from China. What about Giant? They're made in Taiwan. Taiwan isn't much cheaper than Western brands though.
So you don't want to pay the cost of Western brands, and you also don't want to buy from China. What about Giant? They're made in Taiwan. Taiwan isn't much cheaper than Western brands though.
#10
Senior Member
Thread Starter
idk how much you care about the finished look, but if you are, try to find accurate photos of the one/set you're eyeing up. Some look more grey, others have a higher gloss, then you have those with massive decals that cannot be peeled off.
I understand that a budget is of concern, but if for some reason you do end up having to spend the loot... maybe you could find a source that'll offer to sell a pair of fronts if you dont have any need for a rear wheel built.
I understand that a budget is of concern, but if for some reason you do end up having to spend the loot... maybe you could find a source that'll offer to sell a pair of fronts if you dont have any need for a rear wheel built.
But the more I think about it, the more I think I may just buy a complete wheel set (providing I can't find just the single front wheel). The idea is I can always set up the shallow rear wheel with a bigger cassette for more hilly courses.
In case you didn't know, Reynolds wheels are made in Hangzhou (two hours drive west of Shanghai).
So you don't want to pay the cost of Western brands, and you also don't want to buy from China. What about Giant? They're made in Taiwan. Taiwan isn't much cheaper than Western brands though.
So you don't want to pay the cost of Western brands, and you also don't want to buy from China. What about Giant? They're made in Taiwan. Taiwan isn't much cheaper than Western brands though.
#11
Senior Member
"... get pushed around a bit in windy conditions..."
It's important to understand what is happening here. It may not be just the drag from the deep-section side profile. The following is all theory in my head, not tested.
First, I assume that this is not just a felt push, but is also trying to turn the wheel away from the gust, because due to fork (rake?), more of the wheel area is forward of the steering axis. Yes?
Second, lift may be coming into play. The cross section of your deep-V rim combined with the tire makes a teardrop, which is similar to a symmetrical airfoil (think a wing cross section for aerobatic places that fly upside down, they need lift in both directions). If you have a "quartering" wind from, let's say, 2 o'clock to your travel direction, the front of your wheel will appear to that wind like an airfoil at a high "angle of attack", so may generate lift, pulling the front of the wheel to the left, in addition to the wind force pushing it to the left, but perhaps even stronger. EDIT: And the faster you ride, the "wind" from the front, combines with the crosswind to shift the "apparent wind" direction more forward, to let's say 1:30. I sail.
So, ideally, you may want a lower side-view area of the rim, lower section depth, but you may also want no V-profile, or, perhaps a V-profile that is a bit less acute, less "sharp" (let's say a 50 degree included V instead of 25 degrees included V), that may be less likely to cause lift (the lifting flow around the V, the long path, curves back abruptly enough that the airflow "separates" from the rim, and you get no lift; This is like a wing moving forward and then tilting upward a bit and you get lift, then tilting upward so much that the wing stalls, lift stops). EDIT: However, flow separation adds drag, due to the turbulence. Ideally I think, you want smooth, laminar flow around the v-rim when going straight, but flow separation under crosswinds, and that is technically possible because the air will need to make a much sharper turn when coming from the forward quarter, versus from straight ahead.
However a less "sharp" V may cost you more in aero drag with wind from the front. EDIT: As stated above, it may be possible to thread the needle and get both. The USA racing rim manufacturers probably know answers on this. Last I looked at the subject years ago, IIRC, they were adding dimples to the rim surface, like a golf ball, for the same reason as the ball, to delay flow separation to reduce wake turbulence.
Just my thoughts.
It's important to understand what is happening here. It may not be just the drag from the deep-section side profile. The following is all theory in my head, not tested.
First, I assume that this is not just a felt push, but is also trying to turn the wheel away from the gust, because due to fork (rake?), more of the wheel area is forward of the steering axis. Yes?
Second, lift may be coming into play. The cross section of your deep-V rim combined with the tire makes a teardrop, which is similar to a symmetrical airfoil (think a wing cross section for aerobatic places that fly upside down, they need lift in both directions). If you have a "quartering" wind from, let's say, 2 o'clock to your travel direction, the front of your wheel will appear to that wind like an airfoil at a high "angle of attack", so may generate lift, pulling the front of the wheel to the left, in addition to the wind force pushing it to the left, but perhaps even stronger. EDIT: And the faster you ride, the "wind" from the front, combines with the crosswind to shift the "apparent wind" direction more forward, to let's say 1:30. I sail.
So, ideally, you may want a lower side-view area of the rim, lower section depth, but you may also want no V-profile, or, perhaps a V-profile that is a bit less acute, less "sharp" (let's say a 50 degree included V instead of 25 degrees included V), that may be less likely to cause lift (the lifting flow around the V, the long path, curves back abruptly enough that the airflow "separates" from the rim, and you get no lift; This is like a wing moving forward and then tilting upward a bit and you get lift, then tilting upward so much that the wing stalls, lift stops). EDIT: However, flow separation adds drag, due to the turbulence. Ideally I think, you want smooth, laminar flow around the v-rim when going straight, but flow separation under crosswinds, and that is technically possible because the air will need to make a much sharper turn when coming from the forward quarter, versus from straight ahead.
However a less "sharp" V may cost you more in aero drag with wind from the front. EDIT: As stated above, it may be possible to thread the needle and get both. The USA racing rim manufacturers probably know answers on this. Last I looked at the subject years ago, IIRC, they were adding dimples to the rim surface, like a golf ball, for the same reason as the ball, to delay flow separation to reduce wake turbulence.
Just my thoughts.
Last edited by Duragrouch; 03-17-24 at 03:00 AM.
#12
Senior Member
Thread Starter
You could very well be right in you analysis. Doesn't change the fact that the bike feels dangerously unstable at speed in a crosswind. Also keep in mind this is a tri bike, so a lot of my riding is down on the bars. When I come off the bars it still feels unsteady, but manageable. Then again, that kind of defeats the purpose of the tri bike.
#13
Senior Member
I have 3 sets of BTLOS wheels that all cost under $800 per set. They've been great so far. They have many different rim profiles available. I have on 44mm deep set that came an get dicey on windy mountain descents, so the other two are 29mm.
btlos.com
btlos.com
Likes For DaveSSS:
#14
Senior Member
Join Date: Jan 2005
Location: Baltimore, MD
Posts: 5,272
Mentioned: 14 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 2387 Post(s)
Liked 2,833 Times
in
1,613 Posts
You could very well be right in you analysis. Doesn't change the fact that the bike feels dangerously unstable at speed in a crosswind. Also keep in mind this is a tri bike, so a lot of my riding is down on the bars. When I come off the bars it still feels unsteady, but manageable. Then again, that kind of defeats the purpose of the tri bike.
#15
Senior Member
Thread Starter
I can understand people theorizing about frame/fork geometry being a factor. But anyone who has ridden a bike with deep-section aero rims---I have one TT bike with conventional geometry and moderately deep rims---knows that a gust of wind has the same effect as having someone suddenly punch your handlebars from the side. Not enjoyable.
Likes For VegasJen:
#16
Senior Member
You could very well be right in you analysis. Doesn't change the fact that the bike feels dangerously unstable at speed in a crosswind. Also keep in mind this is a tri bike, so a lot of my riding is down on the bars. When I come off the bars it still feels unsteady, but manageable. Then again, that kind of defeats the purpose of the tri bike.
Likes For Duragrouch:
#17
Steel is real
Join Date: Mar 2013
Location: Not far from Paris
Posts: 2,218
Bikes: 1992Giant Tourer,1992MeridaAlbon,1996Scapin,1998KonaKilaueua,1993Peugeot Prestige,1991RaleighTeamZ(to be upgraded),1998 Jamis Dragon,1992CTWallis(to be built),1998VettaTeam(to be built),1995Coppi(to be built),1993Grandis(to be built)
Mentioned: 2 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 613 Post(s)
Liked 879 Times
in
571 Posts
I would purchase a nice pair of Mavic Cosmic Carbone SSC wheels on ebay but made prior to 2008 as for Zipp , I would go for a preowned pair of 303 wheels which is the choice if you are buying aluminium and carbon wheels which are less tall 50mm. Other possibility is Bontrager or Hed rims
#18
Senior Member
Join Date: Aug 2019
Location: Québec, Canada
Posts: 2,053
Bikes: SL8 Pro, TCR beater
Mentioned: 5 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 950 Post(s)
Liked 559 Times
in
421 Posts
Windspace have a good reputation. Yoeleo also sells some. However, 500$ is not a lot for a CF wheel. You'll be restricted.
Made in China does not necessarily equal poor quality, but it often does.
Made in China does not necessarily equal poor quality, but it often does.
#19
Senior Member
Join Date: Apr 2019
Location: UK
Posts: 1,344
Mentioned: 3 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 653 Post(s)
Liked 434 Times
in
324 Posts
I would be quite wary of buying a used bike with carbon wheels and rim brakes. As it’s local you can get a good look at it but the brake track on my Edco 45s (made in Switzerland, high quality and cost, not too bad in crosswinds) is noticeably worn after 3 years of British weather. I learned to not use carbon wheels in the winter.
I notice their 48s are less than half the price I paid for mine though. I wonder if they have offshored and/or gone hookless.
edit: ah looks like their rims were always made in Taiwan. Hubs are Swiss and final assembly in the Netherlands. Price changes came in after a bailout by a German company. Don’t know how much they cost in the US, might be out of budget but they’re great quality https://bicyclingaustralia.com.au/gear/wheel-test-we-ride-the-edco-four-8-carbon-wheelset/
I notice their 48s are less than half the price I paid for mine though. I wonder if they have offshored and/or gone hookless.
edit: ah looks like their rims were always made in Taiwan. Hubs are Swiss and final assembly in the Netherlands. Price changes came in after a bailout by a German company. Don’t know how much they cost in the US, might be out of budget but they’re great quality https://bicyclingaustralia.com.au/gear/wheel-test-we-ride-the-edco-four-8-carbon-wheelset/
Last edited by choddo; 03-18-24 at 03:12 AM.