Bike Forums

Bike Forums (https://www.bikeforums.net/forum.php)
-   Road Cycling (https://www.bikeforums.net/road-cycling/)
-   -   50 mm or 38 mm carbon clinchers? (https://www.bikeforums.net/road-cycling/890993-50-mm-38-mm-carbon-clinchers.html)

Brandonub 05-21-13 02:34 PM

50 mm or 38 mm carbon clinchers?
 
Looking for a bit of group wisdom, looking at two sets of wheels at the moment:

http://www.novemberbicycles.com/rfsc-50s/
http://www.novemberbicycles.com/rfsc-wheelset/

My leaning is towards the 50s, simply to save a couple bucks, as they're on sale. The weight difference looks to be negligible. I'm currently using the factory Fulcrum Racing T (functionally equivalent to Fulcrum Racing 7), so almost anything is going to feel like a nice upgrade for me, as well as adding some bling. I'm a pretty new rider and the only competitive events I have any plans on entering on duathlons and triathlons for the forseeable future (blasphemy on the 41, I know).

Any thoughts?

Bah Humbug 05-21-13 03:15 PM

Coming from the resident triathlete, go 50. In a tri you want all the aero you can get. Unless you're really worried about wind.

robbyville 05-21-13 03:22 PM

Well couple things to think of.

The RFSC 38's are the newer design with wider rim and brake track (if that's important to you). the 50's are the previous model to make room for the new proprietary Rail (52mm) which are slightly more expensive and also have the wider track.

Either way you'll have incredible and exceptionally well built wheels, I have the previous generation 38's (sounds odd since they're only a few months old) and use them as my day in and day out wheelset. I was torn between the two as well and went with the 38's due to the amount of climbing around here, I figured every bit of weight savings helps.

good luck

tagaproject6 05-21-13 03:23 PM

Get the 50 and keep the Fulcrum for windy days.

pdedes 05-21-13 03:23 PM

50mm is the sweet spot for aero and weight for me.

jerrayy 05-21-13 03:34 PM

go 50s

great balance between aero and stiff
plus they look cool

Brandonub 05-21-13 04:30 PM

Killer, thanks for the tips all. I think I'll be going 50s.

BoSoxYacht 05-21-13 04:31 PM


Originally Posted by jerrayy (Post 15650995)
go 50s

great balance between aero and stiff
plus they look cool

I don't like 50mm aero front wheels because a crosswind pushed off the road at about 45mph once.

If you never have to deal with descending in crosswinds, you might be fine with 50mm front wheels.

gc3 05-21-13 04:43 PM

38s are the sweet spot for me, having tried 24-38-50 in the last few years, and so i agree with mr yacht...if you don't need 50s for racing aero purposes, they tend to buffet me around on the really windy days, more than i prefer...but they do look cool...and maintain speed a little better once you get it going fast....but i especially like the fact that i can get ultralightweight wheels at 38 depth

BoSoxYacht 05-21-13 04:47 PM


Originally Posted by gc3 (Post 15651275)
38s are the sweet spot for me, having tried 24-38-50 in the last few years, and so i agree with mr yacht...if you don't need 50s for racing aero purposes, they tend to buffet me around on the really windy days, more than i prefer...but they do look cool...and maintain speed a little better once you get it going fast....but i especially like the fact that i can get ultralightweight wheels at 38 depth

I think 38mm is the sweet spot for a front wheel.

50/38 would be my choice.

Jed19 05-21-13 05:43 PM


Originally Posted by pdedes (Post 15650952)
50mm is the sweet spot for aero and weight for me.

Me too!

thechemist 05-21-13 05:48 PM

50s. If you can't convince yourself do 50/38

Brandonub 05-21-13 05:59 PM


Originally Posted by thechemist (Post 15651511)
50s. If you can't convince yourself do 50/38

The main thing is that I don't think I get the sale price with 50/38. I'm not philosophically opposed to it, I'm just cheap.

dleccord 05-21-13 06:16 PM

go for the 50s. the 38s are that deep. if ur going for the hotness

ruindd 05-21-13 06:33 PM

38

FPSDavid 05-21-13 06:34 PM

50mm for maximum cool-looking

simonaway427 05-21-13 06:44 PM

50's

https://fbcdn-sphotos-b-a.akamaihd.n...21160943_o.jpg

38's

https://lh6.googleusercontent.com/-J...t+18-36-06.jpg

datlas 05-21-13 06:55 PM

I also wrestled with this decision.

I ended up going with 38, rationale is that I am very light (135 pounds) and was concerned about crosswinds...also a closet weight weenie and the 38s are lighter.

That said, if you are mostly riding flats and are a little heavier than me, the 50 is certainly a reasonable choice.

Hiro11 05-21-13 07:11 PM

Both are rebranded generic wheelsets at roughly twice the price of someone like Farsports. Go with Farsports, they're great.

Bah Humbug 05-21-13 08:14 PM


Originally Posted by simonaway427 (Post 15651694)

That's pretty much what my baby is going to look like when my Rails arrive. DAMN.

gregf83 05-21-13 08:17 PM


Originally Posted by Hiro11 (Post 15651805)
Both are rebranded generic wheelsets at roughly twice the price of someone like Farsports. Go with Farsports, they're great.

I believe November owns their molds and are not the same as Farsports.

StanSeven 05-21-13 08:20 PM

I used to be worried about wind and decided on Zipp 303s. Last year I also got 404s and ride them all the time even with strong winds. The sensation from wind is just that - a sensation that takes a little getting used to. It doesn't push you over and also doesn't make you turn. If fact, you sitting on the bike is a profile much, much larger than wheels.

So much advice is definately go with the 50s

Bah Humbug 05-21-13 08:23 PM


Originally Posted by gregf83 (Post 15652098)
I believe November owns their molds and are not the same as Farsports.

The Rail is a proprietary mold; the rims under discussion are not.

Brandonub 05-21-13 08:24 PM


Originally Posted by Bah Humbug (Post 15652084)
That's pretty much what my baby is going to look like when my Rails arrive. DAMN.

Don't rub it in! I wish I'd become aware of November a couple weeks ago, I would have preordered Rails. Now I'd be waiting till July, and I want to get some nice wheels on before we're that deep into summer. Gorgeous look though.

Bah Humbug 05-21-13 08:29 PM


Originally Posted by Brandonub (Post 15652142)
Don't rub it in! I wish I'd become aware of November a couple weeks ago, I would have preordered Rails. Now I'd be waiting till July, and I want to get some nice wheels on before we're that deep into summer. Gorgeous look though.

Hey, I'm waiting until July anyway. There's always Soul C5.0 or C6.0 for a couple hundred more.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 02:47 PM.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.