Lightweight Wheels - Does front or rear weight matter more?
I'm still in the process of understanding wheel weight, strength, rotational mass, etc.
I hear (and have felt to a small extent) that lighter wheels make a bike feel snappier and easy on climbs, etc. I'm wondering how much of that is related to the front wheel and the rear wheel. If you had two different wheel sets where as pair they weighed the same, but separately the weight was distributed differently, would that make a difference in feel? For example: Wheelset A: Rear wheel 60% of total weight + Front wheel 40% of total weight versus Wheelset B: Rear wheel 75% of total weight + Front wheel 25% of total weight Given that that wheelset A and B weigh the same in total, would they feel/ride differently? Which would be "better?" Can saving more weight in the front wheel positively affect the ride or to feel it, does the weight savings need to be in the rear wheel? |
The rear wheel is naturally going to be heavier because it has a larger hub and more spokes - You need more spokes on the rear wheel because the rear wheel is torqued more through pedaling.
That said, the lighter you can make your rear wheel, the better, as it is the rear wheel you are turning when you are pedaling. Dropping weight in the rear rim will be more noticeable than dropping weight in the front rim |
Originally Posted by topflightpro
(Post 17390857)
That said, the lighter you can make your rear wheel, the better, as it is the rear wheel you are turning when you are pedaling. Dropping weight in the rear rim will be more noticeable than dropping weight in the front rim
|
The front. The front also moves more.M
My gut says (I have a real good gut) it has more than twice the change in momentum the rear does. |
I was pulling wheelies up my least favourite climb last night. Could use a heavier front I guess.
|
When I asked my wheel builder this question he gave me a lightweight wheel for the front with a slightly heavier rear wheel for added durability. He said the total rotating weight is the factor but lightweight rear wheels tend to have more problems.
|
The front moves more because its the part you move to stay upright (unless you are a new rider that uses your knees to balance). The movement is not the issue alone, it is the hitting the small bumps in the road that are scrubbing off your momentum and forcing you to turn the front to both regain balance and maintain speed.
If you ride a mile - the front also travels farther than the rear. |
Originally Posted by spdracr39
(Post 17391198)
When I asked my wheel builder this question he gave me a lightweight wheel for the front with a slightly heavier rear wheel for added durability. He said the total rotating weight is the factor but lightweight rear wheels tend to have more problems.
The majority of the spoke tension,and thus weight on the rear is being absorbed by the right spokes. Assuming you're using rim brakes, the rear also gets all the torque from driving (disc brakes also transfer torque through the spokes). I'm not sure about rider weight distribution, but I think it also tends towards the back. So, in theory, 32 spokes in the rear would be like 16 up front. It doesn't really solve the weight question, but you need extra strength in the back for a standard bike. Perhaps a tandem has better weight distribution. |
For accelerating the mass it doesn't matter how the wheel weights are distributed. For handling you will feel the lighter or heavier weight in the front more.
|
Originally Posted by Jarrett2
(Post 17390764)
I'm still in the process of understanding wheel weight, strength, rotational mass, etc.
I hear (and have felt to a small extent) that lighter wheels make a bike feel snappier and easy on climbs, etc. I'm wondering how much of that is related to the front wheel and the rear wheel. If you had two different wheel sets where as pair they weighed the same, but separately the weight was distributed differently, would that make a difference in feel? For example: Wheelset A: Rear wheel 60% of total weight + Front wheel 40% of total weight versus Wheelset B: Rear wheel 75% of total weight + Front wheel 25% of total weight Given that that wheelset A and B weigh the same in total, would they feel/ride differently? Which would be "better?" Can saving more weight in the front wheel positively affect the ride or to feel it, does the weight savings need to be in the rear wheel? |
It is also possible that wheels with heavier hubs and lighter rims will accelerate and spin better than the opposite, light hubs and heavy rims, but overall the difference will be minimal.
|
It has been said already, but yes, a lighter wheel up front will be more noticeable and improve feel. A heavier wheel at the rear may improve durability, but that depends on the build and the comparison.
|
Don't know if....
...its germane to this issue but almost every flat I've ever had is the back tire. 3000 mostly road miles on my newest bike and 5 rear flats. Front tire still looks like new and I had to replace the rear when I somehow picked up a large wood screw that tore the casing. Went to one of those flat resistent rear tires which is a bit heavier and dare I say, have not had any flats in the last 800-900 miles.
I asked at the LBS if my experience is typical and he said rear flats are much more comman than fronts********** Before hearing this I thought it was just the bicycle gods having fun making me get my hands covered with chain lube! |
Originally Posted by prathmann
(Post 17391172)
...since you need to supply enough energy to spin both wheels up to the same speed.
Originally Posted by CliffordK
(Post 17392426)
It is also possible that wheels with heavier hubs and lighter rims will accelerate and spin better than the opposite...
|
Well, except for on rollers.
|
Originally Posted by okane
(Post 17392726)
...its germane to this issue but almost every flat I've ever had is the back tire. 3000 mostly road miles on my newest bike and 5 rear flats. Front tire still looks like new and I had to replace the rear when I somehow picked up a large wood screw that tore the casing. Went to one of those flat resistent rear tires which is a bit heavier and dare I say, have not had any flats in the last 800-900 miles.
I asked at the LBS if my experience is typical and he said rear flats are much more comman than fronts********** Before hearing this I thought it was just the bicycle gods having fun making me get my hands covered with chain lube! |
Originally Posted by grolby
(Post 17392859)
This turn of phrase really needs to die, it's so misleading. When you pedal your bike, you are not "spinning up" a 1500g pair of wheels. You are using those wheels to apply a force to accelerate your own butt + bike, a mass at least an order of magnitude greater than that of the wheels.
And yes, rear flats are far more common than front ones. Partly due to the greater loading of the rear tire and partly as a result of the front tire kicking up objects that are lying flat on the road just in time for the rear tire to come along and get stabbed by them. |
Originally Posted by rpenmanparker
(Post 17391343)
For accelerating the mass it doesn't matter how the wheel weights are distributed. For handling you will feel the lighter or heavier weight in the front more.
|
Originally Posted by Ice41000
(Post 17392414)
If they spin same speed (and they do), it doesn't matter.
Assuming tires are same diameter, try this. Line up both wheels valve stem's at the bottom. Ride around the block. When you get back both valves should be in the same O'clock spot unless one is spinning faster. |
Originally Posted by Ice41000
(Post 17392414)
If they spin same speed (and they do), it doesn't matter.
|
Originally Posted by Doge
(Post 17394133)
They don't. The front turns faster.
Assuming tires are same diameter, try this. Line up both wheels valve stem's at the bottom. Ride around the block. When you get back both valves should be in the same O'clock spot unless one is spinning faster. |
Originally Posted by Ice41000
(Post 17395369)
I am aware of that, but is negligible. For most of the rides wheels are doing the same thing. How much slow tight turns you do during couple hours ride? And how much those matter?
|
Originally Posted by spdracr39
(Post 17391198)
When I asked my wheel builder this question he gave me a lightweight wheel for the front with a slightly heavier rear wheel for added durability. He said the total rotating weight is the factor but lightweight rear wheels tend to have more problems.
|
no
|
The old "rule" for the fastest set-up with two different tires was to put the highest quality, lightest tire in back. I would expect the same to be true for wheels.
This is for speed. Not durability. Not safety, just speed. Best stuff in back. Now, you will feel the good stuff a lot more if you put it in front because you feel the steering wheel far more. Ben |
All times are GMT -6. The time now is 11:40 PM. |
Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.