RoboIsGod

Looking at new frames. I've upgraded my current conversion over time and soon it will be time to upgrade to a suitable frame. I've done a lot of looking and these are the 4 that I've narrowed it down to. Originally I wanted a lugged steel frame, but found the only ones I'd like a bit out of my price range (except for the alien, maybe). I'm looking for something that will take a daily beating of commuting, a lot of times on rough roads, but also something that I can take on day rides as well. So, correct me if I'm wrong, a frame that has more of a hybrid geometry (between track and road)?

To reiterate, the list is as follows:

IRO Angus - I like this frame a lot for the price and the nicer 631 tubes. Most of what I've been looking at is 4130 and Reyn 520, but ideally i'd want something a bit nicer. My only complaints is the straight blade fork, bottle bosses and the overall style of the fork (no flat crown :-0). I know that isn't much, but I think the geometry might be tight for what I want?

Alien - Originally I thought I was sold on the Alien, but then did my research and saw some 'quality control issues' (dropouts not aligned right). Decent lugs, whatever paint I'd like, normal style fork, good price. All seems good. My complaints with this is one is the tubing--the site says 'double butted cromo', doesn't say what kind, but at least its double butted? (if someone could shed light on this one that'd be great). and again, I think the geo might be too tight for my needs.

Soma Rush - After being obsessed with lugged steel, this was the first frame that caught my eye that wasn't lugged. I like the clean overall look of the frame, and the fact that I can get it with a threaded chrome fork (ideally this is how I'd like to run my bike). The site says the tubes are 'Tange Prestige heat-treated CrMo steel; butted CrMo rear end'. I'm assuming only the 'rear end' is double butted, not the whole frame? (correct me on this). I really like this frame, I guess my only complaints is the water bottle bosses. (i saw the '10 model--they got everything right EXCEPT the straight blade fork!)

Specialized '10 Langster (steel) - I really like this bike. Nice 'old school' look (minus lugs), no bottle bosses or cable guides, and the decals come off. It's got Reynolds 520 tubes, but the specialized site doesn't specify if they are butted. From the site, the geo of this looks a bit more relaxed. This is probably my first choice, but I don't know how these ride and would like more info.


If anyone can shed more light on these frames, or know of other frames that would suit me well, let me know! You can kind of gather what my price range is (no more thatn $500, ideally).

ADSR

AFAIK those frames are all double butted tubes. You won't get into straight gauge tubing until you hit some far cheaper frames, like pake. Out of those you listed the Alien seems to be the least economical; lower quality steel, but the lugs drive up the price. Personally I'm looking to get myself a Rush in the not-too distant future. I'd probably also be looking into the Specialized, but i'm looking for a threadless head set.

bryyando

https://bikeisland.com/cgi-bin/BKTK_S...ls&ProdID=1298


premium brew aka fuji obey frame.

PedallingATX

Out of those, the best frame is the Soma Rush. I also like the IRO. Have you considered a Wabi frame? They make them out of nice steel, and the price is right. Check it out.

RoboIsGod

I checked out that green 'premium brew' frame before on bikeisland, but dont want/need the cable guides and bottle bosses. not into the color scheme at all either.

Never saw the Wabi before but now I'm pretty into it (the classic). The only complaints I have is the threadless headset and the silly paint options. I haven't seen Reynolds 725 before, is it better than 631? Also, if I wanted to, could I replace the threadless headset with a threaded, and i'm assuming, thread the fork? (now that i think of it that seems kind of silly).

Flash_BeeZy

The langster steel is very nice!! A buddy of mine has one

RoboIsGod

tell me more!

Flash_BeeZy

I was trying to find his pics but my host is down but I remembered that his bike was blogged about

https://m.flickr.com/photos/markcosio/4014201873/

I'm on my iPhone and can't get the jpg version so click the link

alesi

The 2010 Soma Rush come standard with curve fork not straight.

pedalpedalpedal

If you're planning on getting a bike for a commuter, you'd prob want bottle bosses.

Brian

If for nothing else, to carry a wrench.

RoboIsGod

upon further examination i think your right. according to this thread- https://www.bikeforums.net/showthread...ight=soma+rush the '10 Rush comes with a straight blade fork, but then someone added in that you can still get it with the curved.

and I've never used water bottle bosses and don't need them. but for commuting? you must mean longer rides...

dayvan cowboy

bottle bosses are a good thing. it sure is nice to be riding(on any length ride) and be able to reach down and get a drink.

I'd go for a bike that isn't designed for a threaded headset/stem. they may look nice, but jesus are they a pain. Threadless is so much better(i guess of those that means the rush).

Dr Fu Manchu

yeah but with threaded, its so much easier to set handlebar height.

My 2cents... the langster has a pretty nice relaxed geo, (even though on the site is says its a track geo). The white one looks less tarky. I may pick one up to replace my Scrambler frame. Even tho for the price, you cant beat a scrambler.

psirue

IRO has a crashed frame replacement policy. I'd go with them.

pedalpedalpedal

Well I just assume that commuting involves a reasonable distance where one may need to re-hydrate (esp with a bag on your back and whatever). If you use a Camelbak or something then obviously it's not a problem.

I'm just speaking from my experience is all.

veganeric

I have an IRO Mark V. (same geo as Angus) and a Soma Rush. I was convinced I'd really like the Rush so I bought it as an upgrade to my Mark V. At first I thought I just wasn't used to the Rush, then I thought it was just the bars (Deda Pista vs. my usual Nitto rb021). After several months of tinkering with it I've concluded that my IRO rides nicer. The Soma feels very harsh. I think most of this is the fork (flat crown, curved blade). Every crack is jarring. The IRO with the stock fork was much smoother, and with the cheap Nashbar carbon fork I put on it it's butter. I suspect the Soma with a carbon fork would be much smoother as well. My other complaint about the Soma is how twitchy it feels. I realize this is the "track bike" feel a lot of people like but I am not a fan. It feels twitchy, not quick. I'd feel much more comfortable getting myself out of a tight squeeze on the IRO than my Soma. If you're going for cosmetics get the Alien*, Soma or Specialized. If you want a nice ride I'd strongly suggest getting the IRO and upgrading the fork.

*I've not ridden an Alien so those may be awesome. I have a friend who loves his, though he has nothing to compare it to.

RoboIsGod

the IRO definitely seems the best out of all of them, especially because of the nicer tubing. I think I may end up going with the Langster. Its geo is a little more relaxed than your standard track bike, and for the price I think its a good deal. I'm a sucker for chrome as well

alesi

The official words from Soma about the curve fork is found here:

https://somafab.blogspot.com/2009/10/2010-rush.html

Gamewinner07

I just built up a Langster Steel in white, I love it. Sure it's my first fixie, but it rides great and looks even better. Words of warning though, the headset is crap and if you get it in white, it'll get dirty quick.

RoboIsGod

thanks for the info on the RUSH and the the Langster. Gamewinner07, where'd your order yours from and how much did you pay (if you dont mind).

OjaiYoda

i would go between the iro or the langster. the langster looks better IMO but its also the first year for the steel frames, i would wait to get the second steel gen so they can polish it up.

robo is indeed a good drummer. (if thats your reference)

jtgotsjets

I love my IRO. They really seem to be higher quality than the price would suggest. Lots of attention to detail. (For instance, how tiny and beautiful the welds are on my Rob Roy—most bikes in this price range have big ol ugly welds.)

RoboIsGod

Robo IS a good drummer! glad someone knew this.

n8tron

I love my rush. I've often thought what I would do if my bike were stolen but I'd come back to the rush in an instant.

btw, you can still get soma's regular curved fork, though I think the new straight blade looks great personally! The 2010 rush looks fantastic, between the new fork and the nicer dropouts.