Roody

Can you think of any examples?

Rowan

You have read of how New York was in fact saved from the awful nightmare that was horse manure, by the automobile. There was so much horse crap, but it wasn't just the smell, it was the disease risks that it carried. And what you might not know is that when a horse died -- and there were a lot of them each day -- they were left to rot in the streets. They weren't removed.

I remember when night soil carts collected tins of human excrement from suburbs here, and the bath, kitchen and laundry water were let go into the roadside gutters resulting in a pervasive smell. This was in a "lower class" suburb, and it was only in the 1970s when sewerage was connected.

Even when we have travelled through France, in particular, the smell from the road grates for the sewers underneath can be quite overpowering. Add to that the smells of pig manure being sprayed on fields, and you can get an idea of how nasally unpleasant living in the era before the automobile actually was.

Roody

From the Centers for Disease Control:CDC - Healthy Places - Respiratory Health and Air Pollution

BTW, your second and third paragraphs have absolutely nothing to do with carfree transportation.

Machka 

The ease and speed of medical assistance springs to mind.


You might have a look at mortality rates over the years.

Rowan

Again you're reaching. You and your romanticists can go back to the Golden Ages quite easily by joining Amish communities, or moving to the African or Asian sub-continents and joining communities that haven't seen more than a dozen motor vehicles in a year. I wonder sometimes how many posters here have volunteered in such places with aid and relief programs (and for the purposes of complete disclosure, I haven't) just so they can give their perspective.

And my second and third paragraphs go to the heart of the "Golden Age" comments and the apparent desire of some to return to those wonderful days, when the smells of rotting horses on the streets along with raw sewage permeated everything. The car actually saved people's lives, whether you like it or not. And in many respects, it still does.

You can level criticism all you like at the car and the pollution it creates, but as a transport option, it isn't going to disappear anytime soon... because the community accepts it as a necessary part of their lives. Enlightened communities will plan to incorporate multi-model transport modes that include cars. This has been amply demonstrated in Europe and other parts of the world. Make of it as you will America's status on this.

Roody

All I'm trying to say is that I like the urban transportation patterns of the early 1900s. Obviously there are other things about that time period that I wouldn't wish to resurrect. I'm sorry that you can't seem to hold the two ideas separately.

High mortality rates in undeveloped countries are attributable to many things, with lack of cars being a very minor contributor compared to poverty, ignorance, poor sanitation, bad water, and so forth.

BTW, the Amish who don't own cars and rarely use them have mortality rates that are quite similar to other Americans.

Dahon.Steve

+1

A number of forum memebers think life must have been horrible with all those horses. Visit the library and start reading microfilm from 1900 (of your town) as I did and you'll get a very different picture.

I did not see one comment of anyone complaining about horse droppings. Not one! The newspapers were full of stories about weddings, high school sports, social events all being accomplished with no motor coach or bus! There was one trolley line in my town yet not one complaint about the lack of public transporation in the papers.

Life was differernt but not worse.

Roody

And in some aspects, life was better 100 years ago. Urban transportation was highly developed with electric tramway systems covering all urban areas. Wide streets and sidewalks were equipped with public drinking fountains and restrooms for the comfort of pedestrians and cyclists. There were even drinking fountains for the horses! Sanitation departments regularly removed manure, which was often sold to nearby farms. Cities were connected with electric interurban railways that provided efficient low cost travel.

This is not romanticism. As with you, I have studied this matter over the years, and what I say is reality, not a romantic dream. I'm well aware that some aspects of life were worse, and many, as you say, were just different.

Machka 

To each his own.

But having lived for a year in the rustic conditions reminiscent of a time a century or more ago, I don't see the romance of that time. I know the work involved ... and many of the challenges.

However, as Rowan pointed out, if you want to enjoy the romance of the rustic, go live with the Amish for a while. Or maybe in remote areas of less developed countries.

I-Like-To-Bike

Or watch YouTube and daydream.

Roody

That seems like a more sensible option.