Originally Posted by bhkyte

I don't know about American law but,

1) The shoes were not "fit for the purpose they were sold for"
2) You have received bad advise from an "expert"
3) It could be considered that you had a verbal contract that the shop seller was providing a shoe for the pedals you provided and he has failed to provide has part of such.

The shop should fund their own "mistake",mention that it will also affect any future purchases and if you get nothing still consider taking them to court?