Originally Posted by Trogon

There really is no way to answer your question with the information provided. Too many other variables come into play.

On the one side, there are fit experts that use measurements to get you onto the ideal frame holding things like stem and seatpost extension constant.

On the other side, there are fit experts that start with a ballpark frame size and vary seatpost extension and stem length to get you fit to their liking.

The only way for you to know is to sit on the bike and decide what feels right. In order to decide what bike to buy without doing that activity, you have to have a solid understanding of what you need from a geometry perspective. And it sounds like you don't.

Get some LBS fit help, in person.