Do you race? (I presume you don't.)
Do you care about light weight and getting the saddle muddy/wet?
I like the Brooks Flyer.
It adds a little cushion on bumpy dirt roads and trails, and if you are heavy (180+) it is good too.
The cross tires have only so much cushion, so being overweight for my height (200+) I like them.
The weight I could lose is more reasonable get rid of than the weight of the saddle.