+1 on what Neil said.
My wife has had trouble finding a saddle she likes and rides a wider, cushier saddle in a fairly upright position. She doesn't care about speed, climbing power, or endurance. She is happy cruising around just getting some sunshine and fresh air so it works for her. Bike fit and riding style are factors every bit as important as which saddle you choose. Myself, I've been going to narrower and harder saddles as my fitness has improved and find them more comfortable than the "comfort" saddle I started with. I find price and reputation to be overrated as factors in choosing your saddle. If it is comfortable for long rides and doesn't cause numbness or saddle sores, then it doesn't matter if it cost $29 or $290.
Last edited by Myosmith; 03-02-12 at 07:18 AM.