Originally Posted by
jmccain
I apologize for my implications. Speaking only from my experience, I'm slightly taller than you, and my waist was close to 39" when I was 205. You must carry more in your arms & legs than I do.
Which is exactly what he said:
when I told him (the Doctor) my BMI was still high, he said "yes, but they haven't seen your thighs!"
- - which is why we were wondering why you implied that the doctor should be fired. Everyone's different - 205 would be too thin for me, also, at 6'5. My waist is about 36 at 210 pounds, which is where I am happiest, and my friends/family say "You need to put some meat on them bones!" when they see me. Bottom line I think all of us are different.