Personally I like one big pouch type panniers and find that Nashbar or Performance waterproof ones are a good value. It is east to organize the contents with stuff sacks or ziploc bags.

That said if you insist on more than one pocket, The Nashbar MTB ones are OK. They have a drawstring on the main compartment and the flap over that is a compartment itself. I will say that after they had 15k miles or so of touring on them I did manage to rip out a seam on the part with the drawstring. I was able to use them for the rest of the tour and it was easy to sew it back up.

I have not used any of the others on your list.