Originally Posted by
GeorgeBMac
Yes, there is a difference... But I prefer to avoid BOTH of them.
But, the failing to unclip problem can just as easily be caused by a sudden, unexpected event where you simply don't have time to unclip as it does a "brain fart". Out on a back country road those unexpected events happen seldom. On a trail crowded with walkers, joggers, strollers, children, skate boarders, inline skaters, other bicyclists, dogs, squirrels and such -- all going different directions -- you need to expect the unexpected.
I think it is less a matter of personal choice than it is a question of what best fits the needs of the rider as well as the environment he/she is riding in.
A lot of riding skill involved here also. I am able to ride as slow as 1.5 mph and still stay clipped in if the situation warrants. OTOH, I am the first person to unclip at least one foot if my reading of the situation indicates any potential danger - ANY small kids, dogs - loose or not - family riding in a bicycle "parade," folks walking with ear plugs (if I can tell) who don't indicate by their change of pace or location on the trail that they hear my bell or my shouting, sand on the trail, etc.