Originally Posted by
nondo
Hi there. I'm looking for a new front rack to use on my rigid touring bike (VSF T400). I'm trying to understand why the front racks like "surly nice rack", which include a useful platform over the wheel, aren't so popular. I suppose that a clear disadvantage is that the front light has to be replaced with another solution (any tips?). Any other disadvantages? Why are the tubus racks so much more popular? Any possibilities that the surly nice rack would not be compatible with the VSF fork?
Cheers
I've used front platform racks in the past and they just aren't all that useful in my opinion. I use the rear deck on my rear rack to carry my tent, sleeping bag and pad and just don't need more room up front for carrying those items. The lowrider make sense in how it helps with carrying the load but a front deck is just wasted space.
Tubus stuff is well liked because it's well made. Long ago (and even now) racks had flat stays that were used to attach the rack to the seat stays. They were (and are) mostly a pain to use. The Tubus attachment system is much easier to install and adjust to where you need the rack stays to go. And they are rock solid.