IDK about The other tires , My Nokian studded tires are extremely long wearing
I read that Schwalbes Rubber compound needs Aging before Mounting so It wont shed Studs in use.
Admittedly Im not using my studded tire as long as you will .
Here black ice is an occasion not a season.. Im still using the same [26" 1.9" wide] tires
now 20 years later .. still has all the studs ..