Originally Posted by bigfred

Those are very different from each other.

Using some sense with regard to eliminating nonstarters, I encourage you to try as many as you can. There is a reason for so many different models from each of the major manufacturers. Sometimes the correct saddle for any of us is not the one we would first suspect. And, once you think you may have a winner, don't hesitate to test it for a week and at least one ride of as long a duration as you anticipate in the future. There was at least one saddle I thought was great for 40km, but, after that it slowly became my ass's worst enemy.