Originally Posted by
FBinNY
Yes, I said so in the post you quoted (though I said it was third hand). As I said, this case turns on the reasonableness of the shoulder as an alernative, and if it's borderline, on what the city or county can and will do to make it rideable.
This is a bad case, let's hope it doesn't result in bad law.
Another thing, that shoulder ends about 1 mile north of where the footage was shot. The road then becomes 6 lane with no shoulder.