Originally Posted by cruiserhead

Nice! Glad they were so responsive. That's great! Definitely take them up on that.

Looks like improper prep before they painted and not sticking to the metal well at that area
and/or the paint was too thick and the top cap "crushing" the paint, causing it to chip off.
But that's just raw conjecture. Who knows the reality. Profile is just guessing too, until they see the part in detail.

Even if yours failed in this manner, it's not necessarily logical to say others will too.
So, do what you think is right but glad you were not hurt and Profile covered you so well on replacements!