Thanks, I was thinking of trying exactly that, I took out the insole and saw that there is an indentation from the cleat/attachment on the underside. I may do both, buy some stiffer insoles and fill the recess as you describe or in a similar manner.
Originally Posted by
AusTexMurf
Try removing the insole of your cycling shoes.
Cover the area over the cleat plate with your favorite vinyl stickers, trimming them to fit as/if needed.
Two layers or so will provide enough float for your feet to ignore the holes and/or cleat screws.
Best.