Wow...so much good info in here. Thanks everyone!
I like the idea of picking up a used MTB on craigslist if I get more interested in the local trails.
Now the problem is every Hybrid I test ride (the Raleigh Route 3.0 & 4.0, the Raleigh Venture 3.0, the Giant Sedona DX, and the Cannondale Adventure 4) all feel and ride great. I'm coming from a cheap 10 yo hand me down MTB from Sports Authority that has me leaning way forward. All these nicer bikes feel like butter!
I'm heading to a couple more LBS...one that specializes in Trek's and one that specializes in Specialized (that was funny to type). I need more options to cloud my judgement more!