I just switched from a thicker lube to a thinner one. I feel like I can wipe the chain down after application and get more of it off with the thin lube... and it soaks in faster.. If i wipe the exterior lube off less grit sticks and you want the oil on the part of the chain you cant see. many opinions on this subject but keeping it clean is the most important thing, and dont fear tossing it and putting on a new one.