So as an update, to date I've been able to try a few other saddles that I've been able to find either from friends with extras or craigslist.
1. WTB Rocket - I picked up on CL for cheap and have ridden this for a few days commuting (10 miles each way) and found this to be pretty comfy without causing much pinch issues. The longer weekend rides (35 miles) I could feel the seat starting to bother me after 20 miles or so. The seat definitely has more padding and center relief then the Bontrager RXL then I've been using. Still not 100% sold on this saddle, so I'll keep trying.
2. Acquired a Trek Evoke saddle which offer some center relief and a decent amount of padding for the sit bones. This is a commuter saddle from Trek and for my 0 miles commute each way, this saddle was fine. Not great , but ok. I haven't tested this saddle yet on a weekend so he longer ride testing will be coming soon.
3. Borrowed a Sella Italia saddle from a friend that has the full center relief area cutout. Has about the same padding as the WTB Rocket. I haven't tried this saddle at all yet, but will start commuting on it this week to get a feel for the center cutout and if it helps or hurts.
Also so to clarify, the pinching I am experiencing was not with my sit bones but with the pern area that has recently developed after several years of riding the same saddle
Last edited by cdyer77; 05-31-15 at 07:56 AM.