Size: He's 5'9 and he claims that second bike fits "perfectly"? I'm not so sure about that. That's a very small frame. Make sure, no matter what brand you want, you find a bicycle in your size.
Condition: 8/10? For that? I hate to wonder what a 3 or 4 must look like...
Assessment: Pass on both. Too much money for what they are, possibly not even your size. Not feelin' a good vibe on either of the sales even from here.