The 2017 Renegades are due in a couple of months with some upgrades, so perhaps as that time approaches you could use that to negotiate the price of the Renegade Expat.
Another option might be the Raleigh Clubman Disc. Steel, $999, Shimano Tiagra, 28c tires, standard fenders. I've read folks can fit 32c tires under the fenders too. Geometry looks relaxed so it should be stable and won't beat you up.
Last edited by birru; 06-07-16 at 12:11 PM.