Gloves are such a difficult thing for me...
I live in damp / wet and cold yet not super cold conditions. Gloves are always a pain for me. Either not warm enough or not waterproof. I recently found some Chilly Grips in my grocery store that are kinda interesting and v useful. I though I would share. They might work for some of your commutes and are very affordable.
https://buckyrides.com/2016/12/01/gl...illy-grip-h2o/