Thanks for the input everyone! Went with the Hotshot 150 and Metro 1100. Free one day weekend shipping is a thing on Amazon now I guess.
They are both great from first impressions. Plenty bright - I could probably use the Hotshot as a headlight! The Metro has a nice oval throw to it, putting light where you need it. The Hotshot has a very bright narrow cone, but the body is built in a way where it is still quite visible from 90º+
Hard to get a good impression on camera, but here's my attempt. Hotshot is seen from about 90º.
