Old 02-06-19, 02:08 PM
Senior Member
crank_addict's Avatar
Join Date: Aug 2013
Posts: 6,340
Mentioned: 78 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 1029 Post(s)
Originally Posted by clydesdale65 View Post

I personally had a carbon frame crack on the top tube during my first Belgian Waffle Ride. It cracked in the place where I've seen guys sitting on it, The manufacturer replaced the frame in due time, but I was told by someone at the shop not to rest on the top tube of carbon bikes because that is where the manufacturers can save some weight. This was about four years ago, and led me to start buying steel bikes for my more adventurous rides. I've attached a photo of the crack.
Regardless, that bike was still rideable. Not that one would continue to and very unlikely but my point being, its rideable, temporarily perhaps.

I received a Giant CF frame that was hit by a car, non drive side seat stay snapped clean through the mid-section. The rider was only scrapped up and decided to just reset by force the broken seat stay and continue on!

What I found interesting in examining was how stiff the remaining frame is even with the sheared seat stay.

I also get it that things break and bad things happen. But use your judgement and keep a close eye on your equipment, tools whatever.

I've personally seen including reading enough online (including here) of others mishaps, some very unfortunate. What some risk vs others and how you balance that judgement is always going to be there. Do you park or toss the old carbon bike? Or do you roll the dice?

I think the OP is absolutely wise in sharing this subject. Take or learn what you can from it, calculate in your own mind on what it means or how it affects you. Carry on and safe travels~
crank_addict is offline