Originally Posted by
RoadKill
Most of the reviews on their page are 5 stars everything is great, or 4 stars it's great but has a little slop. I personally feel that the tiniest slop would completely ruin it for me, just a guess as I've never ridden a seat with slop. Anyway, that makes me wonder if any of the reviews are from people who do lots of riding whether frequent or high miles or both. My feel of the reviews was that it's mostly people who ride to the bagel shop 2 miles away once a month or so. I really like the concept and would completely forgive the extra weight, but the idea of movement in my seat is a no-go.
Lots of us now (not in commuting but in MTB) are riding dropper posts, that have a
little bit of play. However it's down in the collar, not up at the clamp, so it's not rocking, and body weight times 5-7" moment tends to take out the slack pretty well.