Originally Posted by
phughes
The reason I suggested the Coleman, was your insistence on it being waterproof. The floor is a bathtub design, and is made of a tarp like material. It is very heavy duty and completely waterproof. The tent I linked is also a four person tent, which will give three people room. The fly goes all the way down the sides which will greatly help prevent water from coming in during a hard, driving rain.
It is a great value, and ticks your boxes. The cost is a slightly higher weight.
edited because i'm a jerk
anyway, i gathered your reason before. many apologies. the coleman sounds like a solid option. and, again, appreciation because coleman isn't generally considered "quality". otoh, they make great stoves, etc. so, probably they could make a good tent, too