you can try my candy's out. i wear size 12, so you should fit. i live uptown too. upper east side. give me a shout if you want to try 'em. i should be home tonight sometime between 8-11.
edit: can you ride a 59cm frame with a pretty high non-adjustable (soldered binder bolt) seatpost or a 57cm frame with an even higher seat that can be slightly adjusted?