i use the tufo extreme tape, and i'm fairly sure i'm never going to roll a tyre. ever.
it took me about thirty minutes to get the last one off the rim. it was a complete bastard.
it also took a similar amount of time to clean up all the gunk it left behind.
i don't see any reason to trust it less than glue. [your thumbs and thumb-nails might object to it though]
fsnl
sparky