Bike Forums

Bike Forums (https://www.bikeforums.net/forum.php)
-   "The 33"-Road Bike Racing (https://www.bikeforums.net/33-road-bike-racing/)
-   -   Hit by the SAG WAGON! (https://www.bikeforums.net/33-road-bike-racing/362503-hit-sag-wagon.html)

wanders 11-15-07 02:57 PM

Do those standard releases to these events that I sign, but never read, indemnify all parties, ie organizers, including SAG? It shouldn't on something this negligent.

Edit: "Does those.." -dammit

kukusz 11-15-07 02:59 PM


Originally Posted by wanders (Post 5639763)
Does those standard releases to these events that I sign, but never read, indemnify all parties, ie organizers, including SAG? It shouldn't on something this negligent.

Releases never allow for negligence - you can not sign a release that does that.

ElJamoquio 11-15-07 03:13 PM

I'm pretty sure the releases that I sign waive organizers of anything, including negligence.

ElJamoquio 11-15-07 03:16 PM

I ACKNOWLEDGE THAT CYCLING IS AN INHERENTLY DANGEROUS SPORT AND FULLY REALIZE THE DANGERS OF PARTICIPATING IN THIS EVENT, FULLY ASSUME THE RISKS ASSOCIATED WITH SUCH PARTICIPATION INCLUDING, THE RELEASEES’ OWN NEGLIGENCE. I HEREBY WAIVE, RELEASE, DISCHARGE, HOLD HARMLESS, AND PROMISE TO INDEMNIFYAND NOT TO SUE...


http://www.usacycling.org/forms/rider_release.pdf

GatorFL 11-15-07 03:16 PM

It was an open course, so I'm going through his auto insurance b/c he turned without signaling, causing a collision.....just like if I was driving. It wasn't USCF, but I'm too lazy to look up the USAT waiver.

GatorFL 11-15-07 03:19 PM


Originally Posted by waterrockets (Post 5639462)
Someone like Calfee can repair that plasma's der hanger, and can probably even convert it to replaceable.

How much would something like that cost? How long is the turnaround time?

ElJamoquio 11-15-07 03:22 PM

I think you're SOL if they don't want to pay you.

waterrockets 11-15-07 03:29 PM


Originally Posted by GatorFL (Post 5639964)
How much would something like that cost? How long is the turnaround time?

Based on the posts of others, I'd guess in the $250 ballpark.

DocRay 11-15-07 03:30 PM


Originally Posted by ElJamoquio (Post 5639939)
I ACKNOWLEDGE THAT CYCLING IS AN INHERENTLY DANGEROUS SPORT AND FULLY REALIZE THE DANGERS OF PARTICIPATING IN THIS EVENT, FULLY ASSUME THE RISKS ASSOCIATED WITH SUCH PARTICIPATION INCLUDING, THE RELEASEES’ OWN NEGLIGENCE. I HEREBY WAIVE, RELEASE, DISCHARGE, HOLD HARMLESS, AND PROMISE TO INDEMNIFYAND NOT TO SUE...


http://www.usacycling.org/forms/rider_release.pdf

Just because they write that doesn't mean it's true. A piece of paper does not release anyone from negligent behavior.

waterrockets 11-15-07 03:33 PM


Originally Posted by DocRay (Post 5640048)
Just because they write that doesn't mean it's true. A piece of paper does not release anyone from negligent behavior.

Yeah, it's just like those trucks with the sign that says "Stay back 500 ft. NOT responsible for broken windshields." I'll guarantee that company would buy me a new windshield.

urbanknight 11-15-07 03:34 PM

^^ Correct. Those waivers are about as valid as toilet paper in a courtroom.

kensuf 11-15-07 03:37 PM


Originally Posted by DocRay (Post 5640048)
Just because they write that doesn't mean it's true. A piece of paper does not release anyone from negligent behavior.

In Florida, liability releases have held up in court for years. Maybe we can get Merlinextralight to weigh in on this matter, but it's my understanding is a well written liability release is pretty tough to get out of.

Shoot, considering the accident was in Miami, he's lucky the driver had insurance.

kukusz 11-15-07 04:04 PM


Originally Posted by ElJamoquio (Post 5639939)
THE RELEASEES’ OWN NEGLIGENCE. I HEREBY WAIVE, RELEASE, DISCHARGE, HOLD HARMLESS, AND PROMISE TO INDEMNIFYAND NOT TO SUE...

You can not sign away your right to sue someone of gross negligence against you (i.e., running into you with a car when they are the SAG car). I mean, you can sign a piece of paper, but it is not enforceable. If someone is negligent, you can sue. It does depend on the state, however.

See here.

[edit] ok like 10 people before me said the same thing...

GatorFL 11-15-07 04:48 PM


Originally Posted by kensuf (Post 5640118)
Shoot, considering the accident was in Miami, he's lucky the driver had insurance.

and spoke English

Chasing Dreams 11-15-07 04:48 PM

From my law & ethics course at university, I have learned from examples that whether you can successfully sue or not will depend on the judge that you get and whether or not the terms of the contract you signed is deemed unconscionable or not by the judge.

When you attend a sporting event and pay to participate, you are entering into an implied contract with the organizing body. The organizing party "invites" you to participate with the general understanding that they owe you a duty of care. The waiver form is part of this contract.

*One way to interpret the situation is that since the organzing party did not properly instruct their drivers out on the course about what maneuvers they could make, they did not carry out their duty of care and caused massive trauma to you. The massive trauma caused you to withdraw from the race. This was a gross violation of the contract (because you cannot fulfil the contract) and it is so flagarant that the entire contract is now void, including the waiver.

*This may not be a good interpretation of your situation.

In general, the waiver you signed is valid and will protect the organizing parties. Unless there is criminal activities going on, a fundamental breach of the contract, or you get a leg torn off and have a sympathetic judge, you won't be successful in suing.

As for your economic loss, I don't see much light, much less some photons.

pinky 11-15-07 05:15 PM

Yet it has the aerodynamic quality of a mildy-rounded brick. Those funny Spaniards.

patentcad 11-15-07 10:12 PM


Originally Posted by GatorFL (Post 5640505)
and spoke English

And had any memory of the incident.

Geoff326 11-15-07 11:36 PM

I hate drivers that don't signal.

elgalad 11-15-07 11:50 PM


Originally Posted by Geoff326 (Post 5642576)
I hate drivers.

fixed ;)

fly:yes/land:no 11-17-07 11:38 AM

first, to be clear, i am a law student, so read what i type with a grain of salt, an eye towards criticism, and NOT as legal advice.

see Banfield v. Lewis.

for those with westlaw or lexis, that is 589 So.2d 441

i'm assuming that you are in florida, gatorfl. florida, although looking in disfavor at waivers that include the negligence (active or passive) on the part of promoters, says that such waivers can be effective so long as they are clear and unequivocal. depending on how your waiver was phrased, i am not sure that you would be able to get very far with this claim. in the case i cited, a woman in a triathlon was injured by a motor car (albeit not operated by organizers, but a citizen not involved with the race) and was not able to make it past summary judgment.

this case has been confirmed in several other cases as well. there are arguments to be made about unconsionabilty of the waiver as well as public policy concerns and uneven bargaining power, but all of these were mentioned in banfield, and none went anywhere. the fact that gatorfl was struck by one of the organizer's cars would be slightly different from the case, but based on the arguments presented in banfield and the fact that this case didn't even get to trial, my guess would be that there isn't much chance of scaring them into a settlement and an even smaller chance of winning anything.

merlinextraligh 11-19-07 12:29 PM


Originally Posted by GatorFL (Post 5639941)
It was an open course, so I'm going through his auto insurance b/c he turned without signaling, causing a collision.....just like if I was driving. It wasn't USCF, but I'm too lazy to look up the USAT waiver.


Another option is your own PIP coverage on your own auto policy. In fact, if you don't have a permanent injury, or medical bills over $10,000, that may be your only remedy under Florida No Fault. (which is in a collosal state of turmoil right now thanks to the Legislature.)

Talk to your insurance agent, and read your policy.

Johnny Rad 11-19-07 10:07 PM

Is that Specialized fork a "lefty?"

GatorFL 11-20-07 02:05 PM


Originally Posted by merlinextraligh (Post 5660303)
Another option is your own PIP coverage on your own auto policy. In fact, if you don't have a permanent injury, or medical bills over $10,000, that may be your only remedy under Florida No Fault. (which is in a collosal state of turmoil right now thanks to the Legislature.)

Talk to your insurance agent, and read your policy.

I have PIP...medical isn't the problem. I just want a not-broken bike. The adjuster here in town seems really cool and is easy to deal with. They'll be paying for a bike, but right now the trouble is determining how much it is worth and what exactly needs to be paid for. Oh, and Florida No Fault is an idiot idea.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 03:46 PM.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.