Bike Forums

Bike Forums (https://www.bikeforums.net/forum.php)
-   "The 33"-Road Bike Racing (https://www.bikeforums.net/33-road-bike-racing/)
-   -   Mt Rushmore of US Cycling (https://www.bikeforums.net/33-road-bike-racing/534454-mt-rushmore-us-cycling.html)

merlinextraligh 04-24-09 09:32 AM

Mt Rushmore of US Cycling
 
ESPN did a thing about each state's "Mt Rushmore of sports" i.e. picking the 4 icons for each state.

The Hampsten interview linked in another thread suggests that Hampsten would be on USA's cycling Mt Rushmore.

Would he?

To me, Major Taylor, Greg Lemond, and Lance Armstrong are locks. Hampsten is an obvious candidate for the 4th spot.

But is Hampsten a lock?

Other candidates?

MDcatV 04-24-09 09:39 AM

Davis Phinney has to be in the conversation; as does ned overend

bdcheung 04-24-09 09:43 AM

There are a lot of disciplines aside from Road which deserve consideration.

Or are we just talking about the Road Cycling Mt. Rushmore?

merlinextraligh 04-24-09 10:09 AM

All male US cycling, hence Major Taylor. Taylor makes it imho because he was so dominant on the track, and track racing was the major cycling discipline of the day. I'm not aware of any other track guys, that I would put up there.

And for me, you'd have to really standout as a mountain biker to make it.

wfrogge 04-24-09 10:11 AM

Tinker, Matt Hoffman, Lemond, Taylor


Thread closed

wfrogge 04-24-09 10:15 AM


Originally Posted by merlinextraligh (Post 8792929)
All male US cycling, hence Major Taylor. Taylor makes it imho because he was so dominant on the track, and track racing was the major cycling discipline of the day. I'm not aware of any other track guys, that I would put up there.

And for me, you'd have to really standout as a mountain biker to make it.

Marty Nothstein

merlinextraligh 04-24-09 10:17 AM

I think the 4th pic gets a little bit difficult. I can see a case for Overend, but MTB was still somewhat of a fringe discipline when he won his World Championships.

I'd probably vote for the Cash Register because he was so dominant in US racing and the two TDF stages gives him some international cred (and I like him better than Hampsten.)

But its hard to put him above Hampsten , the only american to win the Giro, 4th in the TDF, an epic TDF stage win, and the Tour of Switzerland.

I would have made a case for Floyd, but that went out with the Jack Daniels.

merlinextraligh 04-24-09 10:21 AM


Originally Posted by wfrogge (Post 8792974)
Marty Nothstein


Good point, but track cycling is such a fringe discipline, particularly in the US. How do you compare his accomplished on the track to road cyclists.

When Nothstein did take to the road, my recollection was he was kind of average, which may not be totally fair given the point he was in in his career.

But if we're trying to pick 4 icon's, it's going to be difficult to make it from what is largely an obscure discipline.

merlinextraligh 04-24-09 10:23 AM


Originally Posted by wfrogge (Post 8792948)
Tinker, Matt Hoffman, Lemond, Taylor


Thread closed

Don't you need to get back to Playstation?:rolleyes:

MDcatV 04-24-09 10:39 AM


Originally Posted by wfrogge (Post 8792948)
Tinker, Matt Hoffman, Lemond, Taylor


Thread closed

I had to google 2 of these.

after doing so, I post a :rolleyes: and move that this thread stay open.

TheJackMove 04-24-09 10:45 AM

Bob Roll, but just because the volume of stone they would need to remove to to create a likeness of the gap between his teeth could be used to build second monument, the Mt. Rushmore of BF, with botto, Pcad, RyanF and Tom Stormcrowe on it.

esammuli 04-24-09 10:46 AM

Just to throw it out there, Connie Carpenter should at least be in the discussion.

bdcheung 04-24-09 10:51 AM


Originally Posted by esammuli (Post 8793194)
Just to throw it out there, Connie Carpenter should at least be in the discussion.

Agreed, but OP said membership on this mountain requires a Y chromosome.

Racer Ex 04-24-09 10:59 AM

Ignatz Schwinn.

mikearena 04-24-09 11:00 AM

Ha! This is totally not completely related to the topic at hand, but close enough that I don't feel bad about it.

I made this messenger bag for a friend a while back.

http://i246.photobucket.com/albums/g...e/DSCF1972.jpg

Snap 04-24-09 06:43 PM

I realize he's not American, but how bout Eddie B. or Jim Ochowicz?

Creakyknees 04-27-09 11:01 AM

why's it have to be all male? is OP a chauvinist?

Lemond and Armstrong, sure. People who took the sport to another level, both globally and at home. That would put Major Taylor on the map. Frank Kramer as well, or is he an also-ran compared to Taylor?

Sheila Young... Connie C...

Phinney?

John Howard?

George Mount?

merlinextraligh 04-27-09 11:14 AM


Originally Posted by Creakyknees (Post 8808623)
why's it have to be all male? is OP a chauvinist?

Because it's very difficult to compare across Gender. Particularly given the disparate opportunities available for women cyclists.

They can have their own Mt Rushmore.

kensuf 04-27-09 12:06 PM


Originally Posted by MDcatV (Post 8792726)
Davis Phinney has to be in the conversation; as does ned overend

Ned. He's still kicking ass and taking names.

botto 04-27-09 02:22 PM

hampsten, without a shadow of a doubt.

patentcad 04-27-09 02:44 PM

20 posts and not one mention of Pcad? What's up with that?

Creakyknees 04-27-09 11:22 PM


Originally Posted by merlinextraligh (Post 8808713)
Because it's very difficult to compare across Gender. Particularly given the disparate opportunities available for women cyclists.

They can have their own Mt Rushmore.

hmmm... kinda "separate but equal" right?

CrimsonKarter21 04-28-09 12:08 AM

How about the first Euro-Pro American cyclist since Marshall Taylor lit it up in 1900 and 1902?

Jonathan "Jacques" Boyer

botto 04-28-09 01:30 AM


Originally Posted by CrimsonKarter21 (Post 8812527)
How about the first Euro-Pro American cyclist since Marshall Taylor lit it up in 1900 and 1902?

Jonathan "Jacques" Boyer

something makes me think that a convicted child molester night not be the best candidate.

Homebrew01 04-28-09 04:27 AM

Wayne Stetina


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 05:15 AM.


Copyright 2018 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.